Jump to a key chapter
Primate City Definition
Primate cities have the highest population of an entire country, hosting at least twice the population of the second largest city. Primate cities are usually highly-developed and major functions (economic, political, and cultural) are performed there. Other cities in the country tend to be smaller and less developed, with most national focus revolving around the primate city. The primate city rule is primarily a theory before it is a rule.
There are numerous reasons why primate cities develop instead of following the rank-size rule. This can depend on socioeconomic factors, physical geography, and historical events. The primate city concept is meant to explain why some countries have one major city, whereas other countries have smaller cities scattered around their country.
The primate city theory has been largely debunked, but it can provide insight into the development of geographic thought for a generation of geographers trying to understand city sizes and growth patterns.
Primate City Rule
Mark Jefferson re-iterated urban primacy as the primate city rule in 19391:
[A primate city is] at least twice as large as the next largest city and more than twice as significant"
Essentially, a primate city is considerably larger and more influential than any other city within a country. Jefferson argued that a primate city has the greatest national influence, and 'unifies' the country together. For a primate city to be achieved, a country had to reach a level of 'maturity' to attain the level of regional and global influence.
It's important to note, Jefferson was not the first geographer to theorize a primate city rule. Geographers and scholars before him attempted to understand the complexity of countries and cities at a time of limited technology and increasingly complex economic, social, and urban phenomena.
At the time, Jefferson's rule was applied to developed countries, with the exception of the US. Many geographers afterward attributed the primate city rule to developing countries, albeit more negatively. Whereas it was believed to be a positive thing before the 1940s, a harsher narrative began when describing rising population growth in cities of the developing world. The primate city concept was sometimes used to justify racist attitudes of the time.
Characteristics of a Primate City
Common characteristics of a primate city included patterns seen in most large, dense cities. Countries have changed dramatically since these characteristics have been set. However, they can generally be attributed to major cities in developing countries.
A primate city will have a very large population in comparison to other cities within the country, and may even be considered a megacity or metacity globally. It will have a well-established transportation and communication system that aims to connect all parts of the country to the city. It will be a hub for major businesses, with most financial institutions and foreign investment concentrated there.
A primate city is similar to other major capital cities in that it can provide educational and economic opportunities that other parts of the country cannot. A city is considered a primate city when it's compared to other towns and cities within the country. If it's strikingly larger and more influential, it's likely a primate city.
Rank Size Rule vs Primate City
The primate city concept is usually taught alongside the rank-size rule. This is because the distribution and size of cities vary not only between countries but also between different time periods. Whereas Europe and North America experienced industrialization, urbanization, and population growth earlier (the late 1800s), other countries and regions in the world experienced these developments later (the mid-1900s).
The rank-size rule is based on George Kingsley Zipf's power distribution theory. Essentially it states that in some countries, cities can be ranked from largest to smallest, with a predictable rate of decrease in size. For instance, let's say the largest city's population is 9 million. The second largest city would then have about half of that or 4.5 million. The third largest city would then have 3 million people (a 1/3rd of the population), and so on.
Similar to the primate city rule, the rank-size rule is an outdated statistical model to apply to cities. There have been numerous journal articles using the same rule in different countries around the world. One of the main conclusions is that this theory can only apply to a small set of countries, namely some sub-samples in the US and China.3 Without larger evidence for this rule to apply, it seems likely irrelevant in describing the distribution of cities.
Criticisms of the Primate City
There are several criticisms both of primate cities themselves, as well as the theory behind them. While primate cities have a lot of influence within their respective countries, this can lead to political and economic marginalization.4 As the focus of development is placed primarily on the primate city, other areas of a country may be neglected. This can be detrimental to ongoing development in a country.
The theory behind the primate city was published during a time when many colonies were just gaining independence. Many countries began industrializing and experiencing population growth in major cities. Jefferson's theory primarily discussed the maturity and influence of major cities in industrialized countries such as London, Paris, and Moscow.5 However, the timing of his theory alongside the independence of European colonies shifted the discussion. Over time, new associations of the primate city were applied to developing countries, with more negative characteristics. This has changed the definition of the primate city, with a lack of consensus on the negatives, positives, and overall characteristics of this theory.
Primate City Example
There are several notable examples of primate cities worldwide, both in developed and developing countries. The major differences between primate cities have to do with when they were established, over which period of time cities grew and urbanized, and the leading causes for expansion.
Primate City of the UK
The UK's primate city is London, with a population of over 9.5 million. The second largest city in the UK is Birmingham, with a population of just over 1 million. The rest of the cities in the UK largely hover below a million, disqualifying the UK from following the rank-size rule.
London is known for its international influence in business, education, culture, and recreation. It hosts the location of many international headquarters, as well as a diverse set of businesses and services in the quaternary sector.
London's initial growth and urbanization arose from rapid immigration beginning in the 1800s. Although it has slowed significantly, London is still a major hub for international migrants and provides many opportunities for people looking for new opportunities or a higher quality of life.
Given the absence of cars for centuries, London is very dense. However, with continued growth, suburban sprawl has become an issue. A lack of housing affordability is fueling this development, contributing to deteriorating air quality levels as more cars need to enter the city from outside the urban core.
Primate City of Mexico
A notable case of a primate city is Mexico City, Mexico. The city itself has a population of around 9 million people, while the greater metropolitan area as a whole has a population of around 22 million. Previously known as Tenochtitlan, it was the host of one of the earliest known civilizations in the Americas, the Aztecs. Mexico has experienced major conquests and wars between both European powers and the US in the last few centuries, with Mexico City as the center for most of these conflicts.
Mexico City's explosion in population size started after WWII, as the city began investing in the construction of universities, metro systems, and supporting infrastructures. Both local and international industries began building factories and headquarters in and around Mexico City. By the 1980s, most higher-paying jobs in Mexico were located in Mexico City, creating an ever-increasing incentive to move toward the capital.
The location of Mexico City within a valley complicates both its growth and environmental state. Previously, Tenochtitlan was built along a series of small islands within Lake Texcoco. Lake Texcoco has been draining steadily as the city continues to expand. Unfortunately, with groundwater depletions, the ground is experiencing both sinking and flooding, causing hazards for residents. Compounded with rapid industrialization and urbanization within the Valley of Mexico, both air and water quality levels have fallen.
Primate City - Key takeaways
- Primate cities have the highest population of an entire country, hosting at least twice the population of the second largest city.
- Primate cities are usually highly-developed and major functions (economic, political, cultural), are performed there.
- The concept of primate cities was first applied to developed countries but in recent decades, has been applied to developing countries. Regardless, there are examples of primate cities all over the world.
- London and Mexico City are good examples of primate cities, boasting major global importance and influence.
References
- Jefferson, M. "The Law of the Primate City." Geographical Review 29 (2): 226–232. 1939.
- Fig. 1, Seoul, South Korea (https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Seoul_night_skyline_2018.jpg), by Takipoint123 (https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/User:Takipoint123), licensed by CC-BY-SA-4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/deed.en)
- Nota, F. and Song, S. "Further Analysis of the Zipf's Law: Does the Rank-Size Rule Really Exist?" Journal of Urban Management 1 (2): 19-31. 2012.
- Faraji, S., Qingping, Z., Valinoori, S., and Komijani, M. "Urban Primacy in Urban System of Developing Countries; Its Causes and Consequences." Human, Research In Rehabilitation. 6: 34-45. 2016.
- Meyer, W. "Urban Primacy before Mark Jefferson." Geographical Review, 109 (1): 131-145. 2019.
- Fig. 2, London, UK (https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:City_of_London_skyline_from_London_City_Hall_-_Oct_2008.jpg), by David Iliff (https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/User:Diliff), licensed by CC-BY-SA-3.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/deed.en)
Learn with 10 Primate City flashcards in the free StudySmarter app
We have 14,000 flashcards about Dynamic Landscapes.
Already have an account? Log in
Frequently Asked Questions about Primate City
What is a primate city?
A primate city has the highest population of an entire country, hosting at least twice the population of the second largest city.
What is the function of a primate city?
A primate city functions as the epicenter for politics, economics, and culture.
What is the primate city rule?
The primate city 'rule' is that the population is at least double that of the second largest city in a country.
Why does the United States not have a primate city?
The US has a collection of differently-sized cities scattered across the country. It follows the rank-size rule more closely, although not exclusively.
Why is Mexico City considered to be a primate city?
Mexico City is considered a primate city because of the rapid increase of residents, political and economic influence, and population size compared to other cities in Mexico.
About StudySmarter
StudySmarter is a globally recognized educational technology company, offering a holistic learning platform designed for students of all ages and educational levels. Our platform provides learning support for a wide range of subjects, including STEM, Social Sciences, and Languages and also helps students to successfully master various tests and exams worldwide, such as GCSE, A Level, SAT, ACT, Abitur, and more. We offer an extensive library of learning materials, including interactive flashcards, comprehensive textbook solutions, and detailed explanations. The cutting-edge technology and tools we provide help students create their own learning materials. StudySmarter’s content is not only expert-verified but also regularly updated to ensure accuracy and relevance.
Learn more