False Dichotomy

You have two choices. Either you eat an apple every day, or you get sick and need to see the doctor. Of course, this isn’t actually true. These are not the only two options you have, but such is the fallacy of the false dichotomy. When writing or analyzing an essay, be sure two-track choices are actually as narrow as they appear.

Get started

Review generated flashcards

Sign up for free
You have reached the daily AI limit

Start learning or create your own AI flashcards

StudySmarter Editorial Team

Team False Dichotomy Teachers

  • 8 minutes reading time
  • Checked by StudySmarter Editorial Team
Save Article Save Article
Contents
Contents
Table of contents

    Jump to a key chapter

      False Dichotomy Definition

      The false dichotomy is a logical fallacy. A fallacy is an error of some kind.

      A logical fallacy is employed like a logical reason, but it is actually flawed and illogical.

      A false dichotomy is specifically an informal logical fallacy, which means that its fallacy lies not in the structure of the logic (which would be a formal logical fallacy), but rather in something else.

      A false dichotomy is presenting two choices when more than two choices exist.

      This can lead to some big problems for an essay.

      False Dichotomy Argument

      Some sets of choices are actual dichotomies. For instance, you can either have a sip of water right now or you can choose not to. To be a true dichotomy, you can’t help but choose one option or the other. You must fall under one category or another.

      On the other hand, the false dichotomy frames a choice like a true dichotomy, but in reality, you can choose “none of the above.”

      Here’s a simple example of a false dichotomy.

      Either you are for the dam project, or you are in favor of prolonged drought conditions in the Western US.

      Even giving the dam project the benefit of the doubt—that it will indeed counter drought conditions—it does not mean that a vote against the dam project is a vote in favor of drought conditions. For instance, the dam might favor one particular region’s drought relief over another. The dam project might impose on native land. The dam might impact wildlife. The dam might cost too much. Someone might think that better solutions exist.

      In reality, a vote against the dam project is merely a vote against the dam project for some reason. That reason is probably not to explicitly doom the Western US to drought conditions.

      False Dichotomy dam example StudySmarterFig. 1 - There are often more than two things to consider about an issue.

      So what makes the false dichotomy a logical fallacy?

      The Logical Fallacy of False Dichotomy

      To understand why the false dichotomy is a logical fallacy, you first need to understand validity and soundness.

      For an argument to be valid, its conclusion must simply follow from the premises. For the argument to be sound, it must be both valid and true.

      This example demonstrates how a false dichotomy breaks down.

      Because a vote against the dam project is a vote for continued drought (while a vote in favor is a vote to improve drought conditions), anyone against the dam project wants the Western US to remain drought intolerant.

      This dichotomy is valid because the conclusion (that anyone against the dam project wants continued drought) follows from the premise (that a vote against the dam project is a vote for continued drought). However, this dichotomy is not sound, because the premise is not true (because, in fact, there are other reasons to vote against the dam).

      Fundamentally, the false dichotomy is a logical fallacy because it is untruthful, which means it cannot be used in a logical argument.

      False Dichotomy in Persuasive Writing

      False dichotomies are dangerous. In essays and other forms of persuasive writing, false dichotomies can influence a readership to see the subject in terms of right and wrong, yes and no, when in reality the issue is deeper than that. False dichotomies engender anger, limit debate, and bring change to a standstill.

      Say that a writer argues that you either appreciate Shakespeare or you do not appreciate literature. If this writer is able to convince his audience that this is true, then a kind of elitism now exists among that group. People who favor the literature of non-Western cultures, or who simply hold a different opinion on his plays, will be said to “not appreciate literature,” even when this assumption is untruthful. If such a notion becomes ingrained, it will be difficult to change.

      False Dichotomy Shakespeare example StudySmarterFig. 2 - False dichotomies stifle debate and ideas.

      When someone frames something in terms of “you’re in or you’re out,” be wary. Do not be party to elitism, classism, or gatekeeping.

      If something is debatable, then it probably can’t be split into a dichotomy. Topics like these are usually too complex to be purely thought of in terms of “yes” and “no.”

      False Dichotomy Example (Essay)

      Here is an example of how the false dichotomy could appear in an essay.

      Misato, who is the general in charge of military operations in the story, says on page 435, “You are either with me or against me,” when she decides to order the 3rd armored battalion to attack the robots piloted by her friends, her allies. Likewise, a reader must take sides. Misato is either a mutineer without any faith in her friends, or else she is a patriot able to place the good of her people over her personal feelings. Dividing the argument this way, it is easy to see that Misato must be a patriot."

      This essay passage presents a false dichotomy because someone could argue that Misato is both of these things and more. One person’s patriot might be another’s villain, so it is important not to force an extreme choice onto the readers in this situation.

      Instead of creating a false dichotomy, this writer could have simply argued their point that Misato is a patriot. This would be much better, because this argument could acknowledge and counter aspects of the opposite opinion—opening up the floor to healthy debate—instead of falsely and outright rejecting the opposing view (and any view in between) as incorrect.

      Tips to avoid false dichotomy in your essay

      Here are three ways to avoid creating a false dichotomy in your own essay writing.

      Consider the other side of an argument. Before dismissing someone’s argument as incorrect, consider if they make any good points. Don’t write off an idea as “the opposite of the truth” without serious examination.

      Don’t force your readership to pick sides. When you present a choice to your reader to “join or not join” you, you might be committing the fallacy of false dichotomy. Instead, present your argument and then allow your reader to develop their opinion organically.

      Does this sound harder? It is harder, but take it as an opportunity to improve your argument.

      Consider the grey area, the common ground. Before you split something into two camps, examine what these “camps” might have in common. If two camps share anything in common, then you cannot accurately split the camps in two. To do so would be false, inflammatory, and potentially dangerous. People are entitled to diverse opinions, and not all ideas and solutions are mutually exclusive.

      False Dichotomy Synonym

      The false dichotomy is also called the false dilemma or false dilemma argument.

      A false dichotomy is not the same as a hasty generalization. While false dichotomies can be hasty and lead to generalizations, the hasty generalization fallacy does not split ideas into two camps. Rather, when someone commits a hasty generalization, they reach a conclusion using insufficient evidence.

      False Dichotomy - Key Takeaways

      • A false dichotomy is presenting two choices when more than two choices exist.
      • The false dichotomy frames a choice like a true dichotomy, but in reality you can choose “none of the above.”
      • A false dichotomy can lead to valid arguments, but not sound arguments. This makes their use a logical fallacy.
      • To avoid using false dichotomies, consider the other side of an argument, don't force a reader to pick sides, and consider the common ground between ideas and groups.
      • The false dichotomy is also called the false dilemma or false dilemma argument.
      Frequently Asked Questions about False Dichotomy

      What is false dichotomy?

      A false dichotomy is presenting two choices when more than two choices exist.

      What is an example of false dichotomy?

      Either you are for the dam project, or you are in favor of prolonged drought conditions in the Western US. 

      Does false dichotomy cut out alternatives?

      Yes. A false dichotomy presents two choices when there are, in fact, many alternative choices.

      Is false dichotomy a logical fallacy?

      Yes. Specifically, it is an informal fallacy.

      What is wrong with false dichotomy?

      The false dichotomy is untruthful. A false dichotomy is presenting two choices when, truthfully, more than two choices exist.

      Save Article

      Test your knowledge with multiple choice flashcards

      If you're a communist, you must be against capitalism.Is this a false dichotomy?

      To vote for the party that supports Proposition A is to vote against the party that is against Proposition A.Is this a false dichotomy?

      To vote for the party that supports Proposition A is to vote against everything our nation stands for.Is this a false dichotomy?

      Next

      Discover learning materials with the free StudySmarter app

      Sign up for free
      1
      About StudySmarter

      StudySmarter is a globally recognized educational technology company, offering a holistic learning platform designed for students of all ages and educational levels. Our platform provides learning support for a wide range of subjects, including STEM, Social Sciences, and Languages and also helps students to successfully master various tests and exams worldwide, such as GCSE, A Level, SAT, ACT, Abitur, and more. We offer an extensive library of learning materials, including interactive flashcards, comprehensive textbook solutions, and detailed explanations. The cutting-edge technology and tools we provide help students create their own learning materials. StudySmarter’s content is not only expert-verified but also regularly updated to ensure accuracy and relevance.

      Learn more
      StudySmarter Editorial Team

      Team English Teachers

      • 8 minutes reading time
      • Checked by StudySmarter Editorial Team
      Save Explanation Save Explanation

      Study anywhere. Anytime.Across all devices.

      Sign-up for free

      Sign up to highlight and take notes. It’s 100% free.

      Join over 22 million students in learning with our StudySmarter App

      The first learning app that truly has everything you need to ace your exams in one place

      • Flashcards & Quizzes
      • AI Study Assistant
      • Study Planner
      • Mock-Exams
      • Smart Note-Taking
      Join over 22 million students in learning with our StudySmarter App
      Sign up with Email