EU Legal System

Delve into the intertwined fabric of the EU Legal System, unraveling its complex structure, historical context, key principles and overarching characteristics. This comprehensive guide covers all aspects of this intricate system, from its foundational history to prominent landmark cases and the underlying mechanisms that drive decision-making in various EU institutions. Familiarise yourself with the operational core of the EU and its far-reaching implications in domestic law. Embark on this immersive journey to gain an in-depth understanding of the EU Legal System.

EU Legal System EU Legal System

Create learning materials about EU Legal System with our free learning app!

  • Instand access to millions of learning materials
  • Flashcards, notes, mock-exams and more
  • Everything you need to ace your exams
Create a free account
Contents
Table of contents

    Understanding the EU Legal System

    When exploring the intricate and fascinating structure of the EU Legal System, you are stepping into a world of shared sovereignty, where laws are often unique and moulded by the Member States' collective decisions.

    The EU Legal System is a set of legal principles and laws that govern the European Union (EU) and its member states. It encompasses everything from the foundational EU treaties to specific legal acts like directives and regulations.

    Within the EU Legal System, the supremacy of EU law is a fundamental principle. This means that if there's a conflict between EU law and national law of the member states, EU law takes precedence.

    Basics of EU Legal System

    Looking into the basics, there are few fundamental pillars that underpin the EU Legal System. These are enshrined in the primary and secondary EU legislation and key legal principles.

    • The primary EU legislation encompasses treaties establishing the EU and its policies.
    • Secondary EU legislation, on the other hand, includes regulations, directives, decisions, recommendations, and written opinions.
    • The legal principles feature the rule of law, respect for human rights, democracy, and equality.
    Primary EU legislation Treaties establishing the EU and its policies
    Secondary EU legislation Regulations, directives, decisions, recommendations, written opinions
    Legal principles Rule of law, respect for human rights, democracy, equality

    Foundation and History of EU Legal System

    The foundation of the EU Legal System can be traced back to the aftermath of the Second World War, when European integration was seen as a means of preventing another devastating conflict. The primary architects believed in a system that would preserve peace and promote economic growth.

    The first step towards a unified Europe was the creation of the European Coal and Steel Community (ECSC) in 1951. This economic union between six countries (Belgium, Germany, France, Italy, Luxembourg, and the Netherlands) was the first of its kind, and it set the stage for the establishment of the European Economic Community (EEC) in 1957.

    Fast forward a few decades later, the EEC evolved into the EU with the Maastricht Treaty in 1993. Today, the EU consists of 27 member states, each contributing and adhering to the collective EU Legal System.

    Is the EU a Legal System?

    Indeed, the EU operates as a complex legal system, comprised of various layers of legislation and jurisdictions. Each Member State of the EU is bound by this hierarchy of laws and is expected to adhere strictly to it. The precept per se ensures that a common legal framework safeguards the collective interests of all states involved and fosters collaboration while also respecting each nation's sovereignty.

    Characteristics of the EU Legal System

    The EU Legal System can seem overwhelming for some due to its complexity and innovative nature. It blends elements of international law with traditional features of domestic legal systems. The EU goes beyond the typical characteristics of a confederation or a federation, positioning itself as a unique system of legal governance.

    This supranational entity functions under a system where common decisions are made above the national level, steering clear of direct influence by individual Member States.

    The EU's Legal System is permeated by a principle known as direct effect. This legal doctrine implies that certain provisions of EU law can confer rights or impose obligations on individuals, which can be enforced by them before national courts.

    Here are some key characteristics of the EU Legal System:

    • Primacy of EU law: EU laws take precedence over national laws. In case of a conflict, national courts are required to apply EU law.
    • Direct Effect: Certain aspects of EU laws can directly confer rights or responsibilities to citizens.
    • Supranationalism: Decisions are made at an EU level, above the States.

    The Power Structure in the EU Legal System

    Understanding the power structure of the EU Legal System requires familiarising oneself with the main institutions that form the EU's legislative and judiciary bodies. These encompass the European Commission, the European Parliament, the Council of the European Union and the European Court of Justice.

    For example, the European Commission holds the right to initiate legislations. However, it’s the European Parliament and the Council of the EU that decide on these proposals. The European Court of Justice ensures that the legislation is interpreted and applied the same way in every EU country, providing legal uniformity.

    Let's break down the roles of these institutions within the legal system:

    European Commission Proposes legislation and ensures the EU treaties are applied correctly
    European Parliament Shares the power to legislate. It's members are directly elected by EU's citizens
    Council of the European Union Shares the power to legislate. Its members are government ministers from each EU country
    European Court of Justice Ensures EU law is interpreted and applied the same way in every EU country. It settles legal disputes between national governments and EU institutions

    Fathomably, the EU is a captivating legal entity. The power structure and the laws that safeguard its functioning are purposefully constructed to promote peace, uphold human rights, and ensure economic prosperity. This unity in diversity is what sets the EU legal system apart from other multi-national cooperatives.

    Exploring EU Legal System Examples

    The valuable insights provided by real-world applications and case studies offer a wonderful way to engage with the theoretical aspects of the EU Legal System. Here, we delve into some examples, which will facilitate a better understanding of the application of this legal system within domestic settings, and we'll also explore landmark cases that have shaped the direction of legal rulings within the EU.

    Application of EU Legal System in Domestic Law

    Every law passed within the EU’s legal framework is binding and applies to every Member State. In principle, this means that national laws must not conflict with European laws. There are plenty of examples in recent history where EU law has made an impact in the domestic settings.

    Direct Effect is an essential principle of EU law, stipulating that EU regulations and certain provisions of the EU treaties have immediate effect in Member States’ national law, without needing any further enacting legislation.

    A classic case showcasing the Application of EU Legal System in Domestic Law is the Factortame case. Here, a group of Spanish fishermen claimed that the United Kingdom's Merchant Shipping Act discriminated against them because it required ships to have a majority of British ownership to fish in British waters. The European Court of Justice ruled in favour of the fishermen under the European Union's rule of freedom of establishment. This case set an important precedent for ensuring the supremacy of EU law over national law.

    Another striking example is the application of the EU’s GDPR, a regulation in EU law on data protection and privacy for all individuals within the EU and the European Economic Area. This has had a tremendous impact on businesses worldwide. National laws had to adapt to accommodate the principles enshrined in the GDPR.

    Landmark Cases in the EU Legal System

    An exploration of landmark cases within the EU Legal System provides an avenue to recognise the ways these cases have influenced the interpretation and application of the law.

    Landmark cases are judicial decisions that set a new precedent or significantly change the interpretation of the law.

    • The Van Gend en Loos case (1963) established the principle of direct effect, allowing individuals to invoke EU treaty provisions before domestic courts.
    • Costa v ENEL (1964) confirmed the principle of primacy of EU law, emphasising that EU law take precedence over national law.
    • The Cassis de Dijon case (1979) introduced the principle of mutual recognition, implying that if a product can lawfully be sold in one EU country, it can be sold in all of them.
    Van Gend en Loos (1963) Established the principle of direct effect
    Costa v ENEL (1964) Confirmed the principle of primacy of EU law
    Cassis de Dijon (1979) Introduced the principle of mutual recognition

    The Francovich ruling (1991) was a major landmark. This case established the state liability principle stating that Member States could be held liable for damages to individuals caused by a breach of EU law. This precedent provides individuals with further legal protection against potential breaches of their rights under EU laws.

    These seminal cases have greatly contributed to the evolution of the EU Legal System, providing key interpretations of the law that underlie many decisions made today. Operating on grand scales like these, the EU Legal System continually shapes the mechanisms of modern societies, fostering high standards for rights, freedoms, and economic practices.

    EU Legal System Explained: Core Principles and Concepts

    This exploration guides you through the principal features of the EU Legal System. By comprehending the core principles and concepts, you will cultivate a solid understanding of the EU's unique legal structure, the roles of key institutions, and the rule of law principles enforced across the Member States.

    Understanding the Legal Structure of the EU

    At its core, the legal structure of the EU is fascinatingly complex and multifaceted. The system exists to govern the actions of its Member States and institutions, and it formulates rules applicable to individuals across the Union.

    The EU Legal System is fundamentally structured around two types of legislation:

    • Primary Legislation: composed primarily of treaties and legal acts changing them. Examples of such treaties include the Treaty on European Union (TEU) and the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (TFEU), together known as the Treaty of Rome.
    • Secondary Legislation: enacted to implement the obligations under the treaties. This includes regulations (directly applicable laws), directives (binding to the end that must be achieved, leaving the national choice of form and methods to the Member States), decisions (fully binding), recommendations and opinions (non-binding).

    Legal Acts: Legal Acts in the EU Legal System can be binding (regulations, directives, decisions) or non-binding (recommendations and opinions). Binding EU legal acts must be followed by the entity to which they are addressed. Non-binding legal acts, such as recommendations and opinions, do not have this effect.

    The legal structure of the EU also encompasses several key institutions that contribute to legislative and judicial decisions. These entities uphold the interests of the EU and ensure the harmonised application of its laws.

    An essential feature of the EU's legal structure is the principle of separation of powers. This rule is used to divide powers and responsibilities among the EU's institutions, ensuring that no single entity has unrestricted control.

    Crucial Principles Guiding the EU Legal System

    The EU Legal System is based on several fundamental principles that guide its operation. Understanding these principles is key to grasping how the system functions as a whole.

    Supremacy: This principle asserts the rank of EU law over national law. If a conflict arises between the two, EU law prevails. This principle was confirmed by the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) in the case of Costa v ENEL (1964).

    The principle of Direct Effect is another critical pillar of EU Law. It allows individuals to enforce rights based on EU regulations, treaty provisions, and decisions directly in their national courts.

    The EU legal system is also guided by the principle of Proportionality. This principle states that any action undertaken by the EU must be necessary to achieve the required objectives and must not exceed what is appropriate to achieve those objectives.

    Another essential principle is Subsidiarity. This concept holds that decisions should be made as close as possible to the citizen. In other words, the EU should only act if the goals of the proposed action cannot be sufficiently achieved by the Member States.

    For instance, the EU won't proceed into domains such as public health, culture or tourism, as these areas can be effectively handled by individual Member States. On the other hand, in matters like competition policy or trade agreements, which have transnational implications, the EU would be expected to take the lead.

    Lastly, the EU Legal System binds itself to the protection of Human Rights. A commitment was formalised with the adoption of the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the EU, which brings together in a single document, the rights hitherto protected in different fields.

    The Charter contains rights and freedoms under six chapters: Dignity, Freedoms, Equality, Solidarity, Citizens' Rights, and Justice. It became legally binding with the implementation of the Lisbon Treaty in 2009, signifying a significant evolution in the protection of human rights within the EU Legal System.

    Together, these principles shape the EU Legal System and provide the guidelines by which the Union operates

    .

    The Structure and Substructures of the EU Legal System

    The EU Legal System's structure has several tiers, distinguishing between primary law, including treaties and key protocols, and secondary law, such as regulations, directives, decisions, and recommendations.

    The Function and Role of Different Institutions in the EU Legal System

    The EU Legal System is maintained and developed by numerous institutions spread across legislative, executive, and judicial domains. Each of these bodies plays a pivotal role in creating, implementing, or interpreting the Union's law.

    The European Commission acts as the EU's executive body. It is responsible for proposing legislation, implementing decisions, upholding the Union's treaties, and running day-to-day business.

    The implementation of legislation is managed by the Member States, but the Commission ensures its correct application. Suppose the Commission notes that a Member State hasn't transposed an EU directive into national law. In that case, it can initiate infringement proceedings against that State at the Court of Justice.

    The Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) is the judicial branch of the EU. It interprets EU law to ensure that it's applied in the same way across all EU countries. It also settles legal disputes between national governments and EU institutions. Individually, EU citizens can also instigate cases before the Court.

    For instance, if you believe your rights under EU law have been infringed by a public authority in your country, you could potentially take the case to your national court, which might refer the case to the CJEU for a binding interpretation of the relevant point of EU law.

    The EU also incorporates advisory bodies like the European Economic and Social Committee and the Committee of the Regions, which play a crucial consultative role in the legislative process.

    Decision Making Process in the EU Legal System

    The decision-making process in the EU Legal System is a dynamic interchange that incorporates a range of institutions and entities. The process largely depends on the type of decision being taken.

    For most legislative acts, the EU follows the Ordinary Legislative Procedure, formerly known as the Co-decision Procedure. This method involves the equal participation of the European Parliament (representing the EU's citizens) and the Council of the EU (representing the Member States).

    The European Parliament and the Council of the EU adopt legislative acts either jointly or individually, depending on the procedure that applies.

    The decision-making process usually begins with the European Commission proposing new laws. But it's the European Parliament and the Council of the EU that adopt the laws. They do so directly using regulations, or by asking national authorities to achieve a particular objective without dictating the means, which is known as directives.

    European Parliament Adopts legislation together with the Council of the EU, based on proposals from the European Commission.
    Council of the EU Shares the power to legislate with the European Parliament.
    National authorities Transposes directives into national law.

    These major institutions of the EU Legal System work hand in hand in decision-making processes, ensuring new laws align with the EU's objectives and adequately meet the citizens' and Member States' needs.

    EU Legal System - Key takeaways

    • EU Legal System is a complex entity, maintaining a legal hierarchy for member states to follow, ensuring the collaboration of states and reinforcement of sovereignty.
    • Characteristics of the EU Legal System include Primacy of EU law, Direct Effect and Supranationalism.
    • The EU Legal System's power structure consists of the European Commission, the European Parliament, the Council of the European Union and the European Court of Justice.
    • The role of the European Commission is to propose legislation and ensure the EU treaties are applied correctly; The European Parliament and the Council of the European Union share legislative power; The European Court of Justice ensures uniform application and interpretation of EU law.
    • Examples of the EU Legal System in action include landmark case rulings such as the Factortame case, the application of the GDPR and cases that established important principles such as Van Gend en Loos, Costa v ENEL, and Cassis de Dijon cases.
    Frequently Asked Questions about EU Legal System
    What are the main principles of the EU legal system?
    The main principles of the EU legal system are supremacy (EU law overrules national law), direct effect (EU law directly applies to member states), and subsidiarity (decisions are taken as closely as possible to the citizen if not affecting EU as a whole).
    How does the EU Legal System differ from the UK Legal System?
    The EU Legal System is supranational, meaning it has the ability to make laws affecting all member states. In contrast, the UK Legal System, post-Brexit, is a national system, with laws made by domestic parliament and applicable only within the UK.
    What are the different sources of law within the EU legal system?
    The EU legal system has several sources of law including treaties which are the primary law, EU regulations, EU directives, decisions by the Court of Justice of the EU (CJEU), and international law.
    Is the EU legal system binding for all member states?
    Yes, the EU legal system is binding for all member states. They are obligated to implement EU law into national law, and ensure it is correctly enforced and applied.
    How does the European Court of Justice impact the EU legal system?
    The European Court of Justice (ECJ) interprets EU law ensuring its equal application across all EU member states. The ECJ decisions have binding legal force and directly impact the EU legal system, often shaping laws and policies within member states.

    Test your knowledge with multiple choice flashcards

    What does the legislative procedure refer to?

    What is the 'Ordinary Legislative Procedure' in the EU?

    What starts the legislative process?

    Next

    Discover learning materials with the free StudySmarter app

    Sign up for free
    1
    About StudySmarter

    StudySmarter is a globally recognized educational technology company, offering a holistic learning platform designed for students of all ages and educational levels. Our platform provides learning support for a wide range of subjects, including STEM, Social Sciences, and Languages and also helps students to successfully master various tests and exams worldwide, such as GCSE, A Level, SAT, ACT, Abitur, and more. We offer an extensive library of learning materials, including interactive flashcards, comprehensive textbook solutions, and detailed explanations. The cutting-edge technology and tools we provide help students create their own learning materials. StudySmarter’s content is not only expert-verified but also regularly updated to ensure accuracy and relevance.

    Learn more
    StudySmarter Editorial Team

    Team Law Teachers

    • 16 minutes reading time
    • Checked by StudySmarter Editorial Team
    Save Explanation

    Study anywhere. Anytime.Across all devices.

    Sign-up for free

    Sign up to highlight and take notes. It’s 100% free.

    Join over 22 million students in learning with our StudySmarter App

    The first learning app that truly has everything you need to ace your exams in one place

    • Flashcards & Quizzes
    • AI Study Assistant
    • Study Planner
    • Mock-Exams
    • Smart Note-Taking
    Join over 22 million students in learning with our StudySmarter App

    Get unlimited access with a free StudySmarter account.

    • Instant access to millions of learning materials.
    • Flashcards, notes, mock-exams, AI tools and more.
    • Everything you need to ace your exams.
    Second Popup Banner