Special legislative procedure

Delve into the intricacies of the special legislative procedure, a critical component of legislative decision making. This in-depth exploration offers readers a firm grasp on the basic principles, the European Union's unique application, and the historical trajectory of this crucial procedure. The distinction between this and the ordinary legislative procedure, the role of the Special Legislative Procedure Council, and real-world examples bring clarity and complete understanding of the topic. Academics, law students, and those with a keen interest in legislative procedures will find this resource both enlightening and comprehensive. Stay ahead with insights into the special legislative procedure's significant implications for policy making in the European Union and beyond.

Special legislative procedure Special legislative procedure

Create learning materials about Special legislative procedure with our free learning app!

  • Instand access to millions of learning materials
  • Flashcards, notes, mock-exams and more
  • Everything you need to ace your exams
Create a free account
Contents
Table of contents

    Understanding the Special Legislative Procedure

    The ability to understand the Special Legislative Procedure is fundamental to the study and practice of law. This specialized realm of legislative practice offers unique perspectives on the processes that guide law-making, setting it apart from the ordinary legislative procedure. This comprehension is critical to your understanding of how laws are made and amended in parliamentary democracies, particularly in the European Union.

    The Special Legislative Procedure, especially in the European Union context, provides specific circumstances where standard legislative guidelines may be adjusted to meet unique requirements.

    Exploring the Basics of Special legislative procedure

    The Special Legislative Procedure, as the name suggests, is not a standard route for law-making. Instead, it presents exceptions to the standard or ordinary legislative procedures.

    • This procedure is only deployed under specific circumstances and for specific types of legislation.
    • It often involves unique processes or roles for different legislative bodies.
    • May be used to adopt legislation on specific issues such as taxation, social security, and more.

    Detailed Definition of Special Legislative procedure

    The Special Legislative Procedure refers to a legislative method where either the European Union's Council alone adopts a legal act, or the Council and the European Parliament together adopt a legal act, but not on an equal footing, unlike the ordinary legislative process.

    Key attributeExplanation
    ScopeRestricted to certain areas of legislation
    Act AdoptionAdopted by either the Council alone or by both the Council and Parliament, not on an equal footing
    ExceptionalityIt is not a routine legislative procedure, but one reserved for specific circumstances

    History and Development of Special legislative procedure

    The Special Legislative Procedure has its roots in the initial era of the European Union, where unanimous voting was the modus operandi, affording member states a veto power. However, with the advent of the Single European Act, majority voting was introduced, and the Special Legislative Procedure was devised to deal with sensitive areas where nations might still require veto powers.

    Over time, these special procedures have been limited to fewer areas due to the increasing adoption of ordinary legislative procedures. There is an ongoing discourse about the need and scope of these special procedures and whether they ought to be further limited or maintained at their current scope.

    An example of the Special Legislative Procedure in action is the adoption of the EU's multiannual financial framework. In this case, the Council, acting unanimously, adopts the framework after obtaining the consent of the European Parliament, giving the Parliament a secondary role in the adoption process.

    The EU Special Legislative Procedure in Depth

    At heart of regulatory frameworks within the European Union lies a crucial mechanism: the EU Special Legislative Procedure. This piece of legislative machinery provides the EU with the capacity to mould its legislative implementation to suit the multifaceted needs of its member states. It's a very contextual procedure, tied to the intricate political dynamics that interweave the 27-member bloc case by case.

    Although a departure from the Ordinary Legislative Procedure, the EU Special Legislative Procedure's influence is far-reaching. Its application extends from areas of foreign policy to social security, broadening the EU's ability to ensure an inclusive, effective function

    Key Features of EU Special legislative procedure

    The EU Special Legislative Procedure indicates flexibility within the rigid, legal frameworks of the European Union. It's a semi-elastic system permitting policy measures to be adjusted according to each need, across disparate sectors.

    • Non-standard: As already mentioned, the Special Legislative Procedure is not part of the standard legislative approach of the EU.
    • Tailored to Specific Areas: It isn't meant for all aspects of governance, but enacted particularly for defined policy spheres deemed sensitive or unique.
    • Intergovernmental Decision-making: It often involves unanimous decision-making, allowing individual member states to wield greater influence.
    • No Co-decision: Unlike in Ordinary Legislative Procedures, the European Parliament and the Council of the EU do not share equal footing in Special legislative processes.

    Unanimous decision-making refers to the attainment of full agreement among member states in the council before passing a decision. Each state essentially wields veto power.

    Special Legislative Procedure in EU Law: An Overview

    When it comes to EU Law, the Special Legislative Procedure holds a vital function. Being a more restricted method for passing laws, it is used strategically, primarily on laws that have profound repercussions on the domestic policy of member states or international relations.

    The procedure is primarily determined by the treaties. Application of the Special Legislative Procedure requires a proposal by the Commission, followed by a decision by the Council or shared between the Council and Parliament depending on the area.

    ProposalTypically forwarded by the European Commission although, in certain cases, it could originate from another institution such as the European Central Bank.
    Decision Taken by the Council (either alone or with input from the Parliament) depending on clauses laid out in treaties.

    Implementation of EU Special legislative procedure

    The implementation of the EU Special Legislative Procedure chiefly revolves around two elements: Proposal and Decision. The process begins with the European Commission or sometimes another institution presenting a proposal for a new law.

    This proposal is then subject to various rounds of deliberation and amendment by member states within the Council. In certain instances, the European Parliament may also contribute to the process, although primary decision-making rests with the Council.

    For instance, issues relating to taxation such as the establishment of a Common Consolidated Corporate Tax Base (CCCTB), would typically follow the Special Legislative Procedure. In this case, the European Commission presents a proposal which is then deliberated upon by member states. However, the final decision must be taken unanimously, giving each state the capacity to veto.

    Distinction Between Ordinary and Special Legislative Procedures

    Within the legislative framework of the European Union, you'll encounter two primary routes through which laws are enacted: the Ordinary Legislative Procedure and the Special Legislative Procedure. These distinguishable routes not only involve different levels of engagement from legislative bodies but also influence the manner of policy adoption within the union.

    Understanding the Distinction between the Ordinary and Special legislative procedures

    Diving into the intricacies of EU legal procedures, it's crucial to grasp the differences and similarities between the Ordinary and Special Legislative Procedures. For a comprehensive understanding, this difference needs to be examined in terms of processes involved, the role of different institutions, and the specific scenarios under which they are applied.

    The Ordinary Legislative Procedure, previously known as the 'Co-decision Procedure,' is the most common legislative route within the European Union. It relies on the European Parliament and the Council of the EU as co-legislators equally contributing to the formation of EU laws at every stage.

    Contrarily, the Special Legislative Procedure may not involve equal decision-making by the Parliament and the Council. It is used in more sensitive matters, usually demanding unanimous agreement among member states within the Council.

    • The Ordinary Legislative Procedure applies to most legislative proposals, while the Special Legislative Procedure is used for specific types of decisions as determined by the treaties.
    • Both processes involve roles for the European Parliament and the Council, but their degrees of participation, and influence, differ.
    • Majority voting is usually carried out under the Ordinary Procedure, while unanimous voting often characterises the Special Procedure.

    Differences and Similarities in Practice

    Let's examine how the Ordinary and Special legislative procedures translate in practice, focusing on the salient differences and overlaps.

    The Ordinary Legislative Procedure is an extended decision-making process divided into stages, allowing both the Parliament and the Council to propose modifications and veto the proposal. It promotes dialogue and consensus, with laws not being enacted until both entities arrive at a mutual agreement.

    On the other hand, the Special Legislative Procedure can be viewed as less rigorous, not necessarily involving the Parliament in decision-making. For example, in matters of common foreign and security policy, approval falls solely under the Council's discretion.

    Common Foreign and Security Policy (CFSP) is an important aspect of EU’s external action, relating to the union's foreign and defence policy. Decision-making in CFSP often follows the Special Legislative Procedure, resting solely within the Council's authority.

    Ordinary ProcedureSpecial Procedure
    Procedure LengthPotentially long and multi-stageGenerally quicker and less complex
    InfluenceBoth Council and Parliament are co-legislatorsThe Council often holds primary decision power
    Voting MechanismTypically majority votingOften requires unanimity

    Impact on Policy Making in the EU

    Pivotal to the European Union's legislative process, these two procedures impact policy-making in varied ways. The Ordinary Legislative Procedure, by involving multiple levels of decision-making, embodies democratic ideals, facilitating a broad representation of interests.

    On the other hand, the Special Legislative Procedure allows for the incorporation of divergent national interests. Its requirement for unanimity is advantageous in handling sensitive matters where individual member states seek to safeguard their national interests, proving to be both a strength and weakness.

    An example of this is in areas of foreign policy, where the ability to veto can enable a member state to deter decisions not in its interest. However, it can also impede decision-making, causing deadlock in urgent situations.

    Thus, both procedures bring unique benefits and challenges to the decision-making processes, shaping the dynamics of EU policy-making.

    Remember, Ordinary Legislative Procedure implies complete participation by both Council and Parliament, and usually majority voting, whereas Special Legislative Procedure often grants preferential decision-making power to the Council, especially in sensitive areas, and typically necessitates unanimous voting.

    Special Legislative Procedure Council: An Explanation

    A profound understanding of how laws are made in the European Union is not complete without acknowledging the role of the Special Legislative Procedure Council. Serving as an integral institution in the Special Legislative Procedure, the Council possesses distinct roles and powers that underline its unmatched importance in the legislative machinery.

    Special legislative procedure council in EU Legislation

    The Special Legislative Procedure Council is central in facilitating the EU's adaptable legislative processes. It functions as the main decision-making body in this procedure, holding a predominant role that surpasses that of the European Parliament.

    The Special Legislative Procedure marks a departure from the more frequently used Ordinary Legislative Procedure where the Parliament and Council are considered co-legislators. In Special Legislative Procedures, the role of the Parliament is generally diminished while the Council procures a greater say in decision making.

    The Council's role in these procedures is largely determined by the provisions within the EU treaties. Certain areas of legislation are specified within these treaties to be decided entirely by the Council or to require the Council's unanimous agreement.

    This offers the Council profound influence in shaping policy outcomes in these designated areas, particularly since unanimous decisions provide every member state with the potential power of veto.

    A veto is the power of an individual member state to reject a decision or proposal, even if it has the approval of all other member states, hence obstructing its passage.

    The Special legislative procedure council involves a unique blend of intergovernmental and supranational dimensions of power.

    • Decisions often demand unanimity, hence emphasising the intergovernmental nature of the EU with each Member State retaining national sovereignty.
    • Concurrently, the supranational element highlights the collective decision-making process and the shared aim of achieving consensual policies that cater to the larger Union.

    Role and Responsibilities of the Special legislative procedure council

    The Council's role under the Special Legislative Procedure is diverse, involving responsibilities that range from proposal examination to legislation adoption. The council is often the principal authority in these legislative areas, holding unconditional decision-making power.

    In scenarios where the Council doesn't possess the absolute authority, it still maintains a significant voice in decision making, often working in partnership with other EU bodies like European Parliament or the Commission.

    For instance, on matters related to the Multiannual Financial Framework, the Council negotiates and adopts the regulation after obtaining the Parliament's consent, demarcating a clear division of responsibilities.

    A considerable part of the Council's function under the Special legislative procedure council manifests as negotiation. Member states in the Council frequently have diverging national interests which demand intense negotiations and diplomacy to arrive at a decision that is mutually consented.

    The Council also provides oversight, ensuring that the procedure aligns with the provisions and values outlined in the treaties. This responsibility marks a crucial aspect of the Council's function in safeguarding the principles and purposes of the European Union.

    ResponsibilityDescription
    Proposal ExaminationReviewing proposals for new laws
    Legislation AdoptionDecision-making and law enactment
    NegotiationFacilitating discussions and achieving consensus among member states
    OversightEnsuring compliance with EU treaties

    The role of the Special legislative procedure council dynamically shifts in response to the type of legislation, procedural requirements, and the specific institutional interplay dictated by EU treaties. As such, it remains a vital cog in the wheel of the EU's legislative process.

    Examples of Special Legislative Procedure

    To grasp the practical application of the Special Legislative Procedure, it is essential to examine concrete examples. These instances offer a window into its actual execution in legislative processes, illuminating its unique characteristics, complexity, and significance.

    Illustrative Examples of Special legislative procedure in Action

    With an understanding of what Special Legislative Procedure entails, let's delve into specific examples to negotiate its intricate workings.

    One major instance is the adoption of the multiannual financial framework (MFF), which outlines the EU's budgetary limits over several years. The Council, acting unanimously, adopts this legal framework with the consent of the European Parliament, exemplifying the essence of the Special Legislative Procedure. The Parliament's role in the process is critical, but the primary decision-making power resides with the Council.

    The multiannual financial framework (MFF) is the EU's long-term budget, typically for a seven-year period. It translates the EU's policy priorities into financial terms, setting limits on EU spending in different areas.

    Additionally, decisions in the field of Common Foreign and Security Policy (CFSP) also follow the Special Legislative Procedure. These decisions usually rest within the Council's purview, displaying a more 'intergovernmental' dimension, considering the Council is composed of representatives from the EU member states.

    Another critical area is procedures related to certain taxation aspects, such as Value Added Tax (VAT) rates or establishing new forms of resources for the EU budget. Given the importance of these areas for national sovereignty, member states insist on unanimity, hence, the use of Special Legislative Procedure.

    Value Added Tax (VAT) is a consumption tax placed on a product at each stage of the supply chain where value is added to it, from production to the point of sale. It is a significant source of revenue for EU member states and the EU itself.

    Case Studies on Special legislative procedure example

    Delving into specific case studies provides a helpful perspective for understanding the Special Legislative Procedure.

    For instance, the case of the European Union's 2014-2020 Multiannual Financial Framework offers a demonstrative example. In this situation, the European Commission proposed the regulation, the Council enacted it, but only after obtaining the European Parliament's consent. This case underscores the core of the Special Legislative Procedure, where a more sensitive matter (in this case, the EU budget) required a diversified approach to decision-making.

    Another illustrative example can be drawn from the area of Common Foreign and Security Policy. For instance, sanctions against third-party countries are a regular part of EU's external actions and follow the Special legislative Procedure. The Council adopts these decisions after a proposal by the High Representative for Foreign Affairs and Security Policy. These decisions require unanimity, with each member state holding veto power, effectively showing the Special legislative procedure's aspects.

    Real Life Applications of Special legislative procedure example

    The real-life applications of the Special Legislative Procedure are predominantly seen in matters of common foreign and security policy, social policy, tax issues, and the EU's budget.

    For instance, in foreign policy, EU sanctions against third countries have been adopted under this procedure. Also, decisions related to specific aspects of social security coordination have been reached following the Special Legislative Procedure.

    Similarly, crucial tax directives, like the Council Directive on a Common System of Value Added Tax, have been adopted using this procedure, reflecting its significance in sensitive areas of legislation.

    Furthermore, fiscal provisions such as the adoption of the Multiannual Financial Framework or decisions on own resources for the EU budget fall under the Special Legislative Procedure.

    The real-world applications further emphasise its role in enabling the EU to carry out certain policies while allowing member states to retain control over critical areas.

    Special legislative procedure - Key takeaways

    • The EU Special Legislative Procedure is a flexible system used for tailoring policy measures across different sectors, in contrast to the standard legislative approach of the EU.
    • It is tailored to specific areas of governance and often involves unanimous decision-making, granting individual member states more influence.
    • In comparison to the Ordinary Legislative Procedure, the Special Legislative Procedure usually doesn't grant equal decision-making power to the Parliament and the Council.
    • The application of the Special Legislative Procedure requires a proposal by the Commission, and a decision by the Council or shared between the Council and Parliament depending on the area.
    • The Distinction between the Ordinary and Special Legislative Procedures lies in the processes involved, the role of different institutions, and the specific scenarios under which they are applied— with the Ordinary Legislative Procedure involving multiple levels of decision-making and the Special Legislative Procedure requiring unanimity.
    Special legislative procedure Special legislative procedure
    Learn with 15 Special legislative procedure flashcards in the free StudySmarter app

    We have 14,000 flashcards about Dynamic Landscapes.

    Sign up with Email

    Already have an account? Log in

    Frequently Asked Questions about Special legislative procedure
    What is the significance of the special legislative procedure in UK Parliament?
    The special legislative procedure in UK Parliament allows for detailed scrutiny and consideration of legislation with significant impact. It ensures that any potential implications are thoroughly examined, fostering more informed decision-making and robust laws.
    How does the special legislative procedure differ from the ordinary legislative process in the UK Parliament?
    The special legislative procedure in the UK Parliament is different from the ordinary process because it grants certain proposals a higher level of scrutiny. It usually involves more detailed examination and it's often used for private and hybrid bills that directly affect specific individuals or small groups.
    What are the circumstances under which the special legislative procedure is applied in the UK Parliament?
    The special legislative procedure in the UK Parliament is employed for certain types of statutes, including private bills, hybrid bills, and bills of aids and supplies. These involve matters that directly affect an individual, corporation, locality or have unusual features that are beyond the scope of public bills.
    Can the special legislative procedure be used for all types of legislation in the UK Parliament?
    No, the special legislative procedure cannot be used for all types of legislation in the UK Parliament. It is typically reserved for private bills, certain public bills and measures affecting specific groups, individuals or localities.
    What role do the Houses of Parliament play in the special legislative procedure in the UK?
    In the UK's special legislative procedure, the Houses of Parliament play critical roles. The House of Commons initiates laws and the House of Lords reviews and suggests amendments. Both Houses must agree on the final draft before it can receive Royal Assent and become law.

    Test your knowledge with multiple choice flashcards

    What is the Special Legislative Procedure in the context of the European Union?

    What is unique about the Special Legislative Procedure's scope and adoption process?

    What historical developments led to the Special Legislative Procedure's creation?

    Next

    Discover learning materials with the free StudySmarter app

    Sign up for free
    1
    About StudySmarter

    StudySmarter is a globally recognized educational technology company, offering a holistic learning platform designed for students of all ages and educational levels. Our platform provides learning support for a wide range of subjects, including STEM, Social Sciences, and Languages and also helps students to successfully master various tests and exams worldwide, such as GCSE, A Level, SAT, ACT, Abitur, and more. We offer an extensive library of learning materials, including interactive flashcards, comprehensive textbook solutions, and detailed explanations. The cutting-edge technology and tools we provide help students create their own learning materials. StudySmarter’s content is not only expert-verified but also regularly updated to ensure accuracy and relevance.

    Learn more
    StudySmarter Editorial Team

    Team Law Teachers

    • 17 minutes reading time
    • Checked by StudySmarter Editorial Team
    Save Explanation

    Study anywhere. Anytime.Across all devices.

    Sign-up for free

    Sign up to highlight and take notes. It’s 100% free.

    Join over 22 million students in learning with our StudySmarter App

    The first learning app that truly has everything you need to ace your exams in one place

    • Flashcards & Quizzes
    • AI Study Assistant
    • Study Planner
    • Mock-Exams
    • Smart Note-Taking
    Join over 22 million students in learning with our StudySmarter App

    Get unlimited access with a free StudySmarter account.

    • Instant access to millions of learning materials.
    • Flashcards, notes, mock-exams, AI tools and more.
    • Everything you need to ace your exams.
    Second Popup Banner