Dive into an in-depth exploration of concept screening in product development, a fundamental phase in engineering. This comprehensive guide offers a thorough understanding of the basics of concept screening, underlining its importance and benefits. You'll journey through each stage of product development, examining concept screening's pivotal role. Discover effective concept evaluation methods, understand how to select the right approach, and understand the criteria for successful concept screening. Lastly, get acquainted with popular tools to aid in concept screening for more efficient product development.
Explore our app and discover over 50 million learning materials for free.
Lerne mit deinen Freunden und bleibe auf dem richtigen Kurs mit deinen persönlichen Lernstatistiken
Jetzt kostenlos anmeldenNie wieder prokastinieren mit unseren Lernerinnerungen.
Jetzt kostenlos anmeldenDive into an in-depth exploration of concept screening in product development, a fundamental phase in engineering. This comprehensive guide offers a thorough understanding of the basics of concept screening, underlining its importance and benefits. You'll journey through each stage of product development, examining concept screening's pivotal role. Discover effective concept evaluation methods, understand how to select the right approach, and understand the criteria for successful concept screening. Lastly, get acquainted with popular tools to aid in concept screening for more efficient product development.
Concept screening in product development refers to a systematic process employed to choose the most feasible concept amongst several alternatives generated during the ideation phase. The end goal of this technique is to ensure successful product development and market acceptance by evaluating potential solutions based on relevant criteria such as feasibility, cost-effectiveness, and market potential.
Initially, a broad range of ideas is gathered and refined in a process often referred to as concept generation. Following this step, the concept screening process takes over to systematically filter and rank those ideas, catapulting the most promising concepts to the developmental phase.
Concept screening: A phase in the product development journey where various concepts are carefully assessed and the most promising one(s) selected for further elaboration.
Concept screening utilizes a weighted decision matrix where each concept is evaluated against set criteria. This is not a one-time procedure but an iterative process, which is often repeated to refine the chosen concept, ensuring alignment with customer needs and market dynamics.
Example: Imagine a company that designs eco-friendly household appliances. During the concept generation phase, they brainstorm ideas for a new energy-saving dishwasher. Ideas could range from a model with AI capabilities to a waterless dishwasher. Next, during the concept screening process, each idea is thoroughly examined and scored based on factors such as cost, market potential, eco-friendliness, technological feasibility, etc. The idea with the highest score proceeds to the next phase of the product development process.
Concept screening plays a pivotal role in the success of product development. It not only saves valuable time and resources that could be wasted on pursuing non-sustainable concepts but also increases the chances of creating a product that meets market and customer needs effectively.
The concept screening process, when conducted effectively, can drastically improve a product's chances of success. It helps build a rigorous foundation for the development process and saves subsequent time and effort downstream in the development timeline. Thus, it plays an invaluable role in the sphere of product development.
Deep Dive: A popular tool used in the concept screening process is Pugh’s Matrix, a simple tabular format that aids in the comparison of different concepts against a reference concept (a datum) based on a set of established criteria. Each concept is then evaluated as 'Better', 'Same', or 'Worse' compared to the reference concept. This comparative analysis helps in distinguishing the most promising concept(s) from the pool.
In the journey of product development, each stage plays a critical role in determining the product's success. Careful weaving of concept screening within these stages sharpens the focus, improves resource allocation and drives the product down the most favourable track.
Product development can be broadly divided into several stages, each having its own significance. While the names and specifics of these stages may vary between industries, the typical development journey proceeds from idea generation to launch and post-launch review. A comprehensive understanding of these stages paves the way to better understand the part played by concept screening in successful product development.
Product Development Stages: Specific phases a product goes through, from the initial idea to market launch and review, each phase offering an opportunity for evaluation, refinement, and decision-making.
Concept screening, situated after ideation and concept development, has critical implications for the subsequent stages of product development. It shapes the trajectory for the remaining development process, underlining its significance.
Example: In the development stage, without a well-executed concept screening phase, teams could waste resources developing a technically complex product that does not align with market needs. In other words, concept screening provides a clear roadmap for development activities and decreases the risk of misguided efforts.
In the testing and validation stage, concept screening plays a crucial role as well. Here, the product and marketing plan are tested extensively. However, if the concept screening process hasn't been conducted effectively, unrealistic concepts may reach this stage leading to investment of time and resources in validating a product that might not feasibly meet the market requirements.
Furthermore, in the critical launch stage, a product resulting from an unsubstantiated concept (due to lax concept screening) may not resonate well with customers, impacting the product's initial reception and sale performance. Similarly, during the post-launch review stage, if the product's concept was not well-screened initially, it could underperform or not align with market/brand dynamics causing additional revisions or even product failure.
Concept Screening: A decisive process after concept development that evaluates and selects the most promising product concepts based on multiple criteria such as technical feasibility, cost implications, and market dynamics.
Given the far-reaching impacts of concept screening on every stage of product development, it is deemed as one of the most pivotal aspects of successful product development. It's not just an evaluative mechanism but a significant determinant of the product's market viability, acceptance, and ultimate success.
Concept screening wouldn’t accomplish its objectives without effective evaluation methods. These procedures act as the adjudicators in the journey from a mere idea to a successful product in the market. Let's delve deeper into understanding and choosing optimal evaluation methods for successful concept screening.
The concept evaluation stage of product development encompasses various methods, each with its distinct benefits, consideration factors and approach. The methods often used are Pugh Matrix, Feasibility Analysis, and Integrated Product Development.
The Pugh Matrix or Pugh’s Decision Matrix is a popular and simple analytical tool used to compare and weigh multiple options against defined criteria. The matrix includes all the concepts that need to be evaluated, with each corresponding to a row. The columns represent the criteria, which are often predetermined on the basis of project requirements, market dynamics, and product functionality. Concepts are then evaluated as either 'better', 'the same', or 'worse' than a selected reference concept (datum), and scored as '+1', '0', or '-1' respectively. A final score for each concept, the sum of each criterion score, then becomes the basis for concept selection.
Pugh Matrix: Constructed by creating a grid of concepts against success criteria. Each concept is compared with a standard reference concept (datum), and assigned a score based on its relative performance.
Criteria | Concept 1 | Concept 2 | Concept 3 |
Cost | +1 | 0 | -1 |
Feasibility | 0 | +1 | +1 |
Market Potential | -1 | +1 | 0 |
TOTAL | 0 | +2 | 0 |
Feasibility Analysis, on the other hand, is another frequently used concept evaluation technique. Here, the key objective is to assess whether the development and manufacture of the proposed concept are viable, realistic and achievable within set constraints such as time, budget, technological capacities, and regulatory requirements. It may involve both qualitative and quantitative evaluations.
Feasibility Analysis: A studio analysis of how a product concept matches existing constraints and potential future constraints.
Choosing an appropriate method for concept evaluation is as critical as the process itself. The chosen method should align with the product’s objectives, requirements, and constraints, and be in harmony with the organization's strategic direction. Several factors impact this choice, including the nature of the product, target market characteristics, available resources, project timeline, and complexity of the concepts.
Here are a few guiding principles for the selection:Threshold Criteria: Minimum standards or requirements a product concept must meet to pass the initial screening phase.
Objective Criteria: Measurable attributes of a product concept that allows for its assessment and comparison with other concepts during the screening process.
Criteria | Concept A | Concept B | Concept C |
Cost | +1 | 0 | -1 |
Safety | +1 | +1 | +1 |
Regulatory Compliance | +1 | +1 | 0 |
Novelty | -1 | +1 | 0 |
Feasibility | 0 | -1 | +1 |
Market Potential | +1 | +1 | +1 |
Ease of Manufacture | +1 | 0 | -1 |
ROI | 0 | +1 | -1 |
TOTAL | +3 | +3 | -1 |
For instance, in a Pugh Matrix, if you're scanning three product concepts for a new electronic device, you would score each concept against criteria such as cost, power usage, market potential, and technological feasibility. Each of these criteria would have predefined importance weights. Using this scoring matrix, you can easily compare and evaluate each concept based on their scores, thereby aiding in the selection of the most suitable concept.
For instance, when using the Pugh Matrix or any decision-making matrix, ensure that the criteria used for screening and their weights accurately represent the product requirements and objectives. This can significantly affect the accuracy of the concept evaluations.
With Morphological Analysis, the selection of the different attributes or qualities that will be combined to generate new concepts is crucial. These should be as comprehensive as possible to explore the entire problem space but must still be pragmatic and relevant to the product's context.
Software applications for concept screening usually offer a range of features that can improve the efficiency and accuracy of the process. However, to exploit these features to their best, you must:Every tool brings unique aspects to the concept screening process. The Pugh Matrix is a well structured, comparative method that encourages holistic thinking among the engineering team. On the other hand, software can handle complex calculations and vast amounts of data, providing quick and accurate results. The choice among these tools is dependent on several factors like number and complexity of concepts, availability and familiarity with software, and nature and scale of the project.
What is the concept screening in product development?
Concept screening in product development is a process employed to select the most feasible concept from several alternatives generated during the ideation phase. It uses a weighted decision matrix to evaluate potential solutions based on criteria such as feasibility, cost-effectiveness, and market potential.
What are some of the benefits of incorporating concept screening in product development?
Concept screening helps optimise resources by screening out non-viable concepts early on, manages risks by identifying potential issues in early stages, ensures the chosen product concept aligns with market and customer needs, and can hasten the time to market by streamlining the ideation process.
What is Pugh’s Matrix in the context of concept screening?
Pugh’s Matrix is a tool used in the concept screening process. It's a simple tabular format that helps to compare different concepts against a reference concept (a datum) based on a set of established criteria. Each concept is then evaluated as 'Better', 'Same', or 'Worse' compared to the reference concept.
What stages does product development typically go through?
Product development usually proceeds from idea generation, concept development, concept screening, development, testing and validation, then launch, and finally post-launch review.
What is the role of concept screening in product development?
Concept screening evaluates and selects the most promising product concepts based on criteria such as technical feasibility, cost implications, and market dynamics. This shaping the trajectory for the remaining development process by reducing risks and optimizing resources.
Why is concept screening considered a determinant of a product's success?
Concept screening is crucial as it optimizes resources by ruling out weak concepts early on, reducing the risk of misguided efforts in development, testing, and launch stages. Hence, it is a significant determinant of a product's market viability, acceptance, and ultimate success.
Already have an account? Log in
Open in AppThe first learning app that truly has everything you need to ace your exams in one place
Sign up to highlight and take notes. It’s 100% free.
Save explanations to your personalised space and access them anytime, anywhere!
Sign up with Email Sign up with AppleBy signing up, you agree to the Terms and Conditions and the Privacy Policy of StudySmarter.
Already have an account? Log in
Already have an account? Log in
The first learning app that truly has everything you need to ace your exams in one place
Already have an account? Log in