Communitarianism

Communitarianism Definition

Communitarianism is a socio-political philosophy (meaning that it’s a philosophy that touches on both how we should exist as social creatures and how we should operate politically in the civil space). Communitarianism focuses on prioritizing the needs of the whole rather than the needs of the individual. It’s viewed as the opposite of individualism, which encourages each person to prioritize their own needs rather than the needs of the community.

There are many ways we can view the role of government and of citizens within a country. As a political philosophy, communitarianism views the role of government through the lens of the relationship between the individual and the community. That is, what role can each individual play in the broader context of the whole? How can each person contribute to the common good? How can government structures support the needs of the community?

Communitarianism views civil life through the lens of the community. Source: Pixabay

Communitarianism in America

Enlightenment ideas such as the social contract and natural rights are seen as a reaction to the absolute power and authoritarian regimes of the Medieval and Renaissance time periods. They were born out the need to impose checks on government power and protect citizens, and eventually grew into liberal and neoliberal mindsets. Communitarianism is a reaction to these ideas, especially concerns around excessive individualism and egotistical motives.

While the term “communitarianism” was coined in the 1840s in response to a British leader of a communal utopian movement, the philosophy of communitarianism was mostly developed in the 1980s as a reaction to the rise of neoliberalism.

Contrasts with Neoliberalism

Neoliberalism is another socio-political framework. Instead of focusing on the relationship between the individual and the community, it focuses on the role of the economy in everyday life. It grew out of classical liberalism and became popularized in the 1970s as the United States experienced a period of stagflation, which people blamed on government overspending and overreach.

Neoliberals argued that the government should take an anti-interventionist, laissez-faire approach and let the market correct itself. During Ronald Reagens presidency in the 1980's he applied neoliberal theory to the markets and drastically reshaped global finance in the process.

Communitarians criticized Regan's neoliberal economic policies, saying that they benefited the few people at the top of the food chain and increased wealth only at the expense of the whole.

This chart depicts communitarianism as the opposite of individualism. Source: Thane, Wikimedia Commons, CC-BY-SA-4.0

Authoritarian Communitarianism

While the communitarian philosophy was growing in the West in response to hyper-individualism, another branch of communitarianism arose in East Asian countries along with Communism. This branch was called Authoritarian Communitarianism, which took a step further by sacrificing individual rights for the needs of the community. This meant that individuals could be forced to subjugate their own needs if it benefited the larger group.

Responsive Communitarianism

Concerns around authoritarian communitarianism gave rise to a new school of thought called Responsive Communitarianism. Becoming popular in the 1990s, Responsive Communitarianism sought to balance the need for individual rights along with the needs of the whole. Thinkers in this space focused on how to achieve the common good while ensuring individual autonomy.

Communitarianism Ethics

While Communitarianism seeks to benefit the community as a whole, it has faced debates around several ethical issues.

Community Rights vs. Individual Rights

One of the biggest debates in communitarianism is the needs of the community vs. the needs of the individual. While communitarianism can be used to the benefit of all, critics point out that communities can be oppressive. If decisions are left up to the community, it could open the door to majority groups oppressing minority groups. However, communitarians also critique capitalism and neoliberalism, which fail to instill a sense of personal responsibility to the community.

Mutuality vs. Charity

Communitarianism believes that the well-being of the community should be the focus of civic life. However, many reject the idea of charity or aid that only comes from the hands of government or wealthy donors. Rather, they emphasize the personal responsibility of each individual in the community to help out the other members. Through strengthening communities, they believe that people's needs will be met much more effectively than relying on government programs or charities.

Critiques of Authoritarian Communitarianism

Another ethical problem can come when governments take communitarianism too far and start getting into the realm of authoritarian communitarianism. Policies under this philosophy can end up violating human rights.

Economic Communitarianism

As a philosophy, communitarianism focuses on social and community aspects of life moreso than the economy. This sharply contrasts with neoliberalism and capitalism, which view social and political life through the lens of the economy.

Communitarianism rejects laissez-faire policies and favors government intervention to help distribute wealth through taxes (especially for the rich) to maintain a standard of living for each member of the community. As an economic philosophy, communitarianism is less focused on creating profits and wealth than on meeting the needs of the community.

Communitarianism Examples

Below are some examples of policies that come out of the Communitarianist philosophy:

Environmental Protection

When the government steps in to make policies to protect the planet, it impacts everyone. While some people argue from a capitalist perspective that environmental protections can increase costs or make it more difficult for businesses to produce products, the communitarian perspective says that it's more beneficial to protect the interests of the community by mitigating climate change.

Universal Healthcare

Some countries have universal healthcare, which means that the government provides healthcare rather than a person having to purchase their own plan or get it through their employer. It often means that the cost of the healthcare system is included in citizens' taxes so that everyone can take advantage of it, no matter their financial status. From an individualist perspective, one could argue that purchasing healthcare is up to each person and whether they want to spend their money on it or not. However, the communitarian perspective would argue that it's in the community's best interest to ensure that everyone has equal access to healthcare.