Conservation of Number Piaget

Do children understand the world the same way adults do? According to Piaget, children develop their understanding of the physical properties of objects and the ability to reason about them in stages. 

Conservation of Number Piaget Conservation of Number Piaget

Create learning materials about Conservation of Number Piaget with our free learning app!

  • Instand access to millions of learning materials
  • Flashcards, notes, mock-exams and more
  • Everything you need to ace your exams
Create a free account
Contents
Table of contents

    Piaget observed that before age seven, children struggle to recognise that objects can change how they appear but remain the same object. He called this phenomenon a conservation error. Let's take a closer look at how the conservation of number Piaget proposed was investigated and what it tells us about cognitive development.

    • In this topic, we will cover the study investigating the conservation of numbers Piaget designed, which is known as the Piaget conservation of number experiment.
    • Within this topic, we will discuss the Piaget conservation task used in the experiment and evaluate the study.
    • Examples of conservations in Piaget's theory will be discussed throughout to help you understand this topic.

    Conservation of number Piaget, Three images of the same child first confused then thinking and finally understanding, StudySmarterFig. 1 - At the beginning of the preoperational stage, children do not understand the concept of conservation, but by the end, they can understand it.

    What is Piaget's Theory of Cognitive Development?

    Piaget's observations started with his own children. He noticed that children of different ages make specific mistakes that reflect their level of cognitive development. Piaget outlined four stages of cognitive development, universal for every child. Based on the theory of conservation, we will focus on the first two stages:

    • First is the sensorimotor stage, which lasts until two years of age; in this stage, children learn about the world through senses and interactions and develop the ability to represent objects that are not around them mentally.

    For example, children in the first stage of cognitive development (before eight months) have not understood object permanence and believe that objects stop existing when they are out of sight.

    • And the second is the pre-operational stage which lasts until the age of 7. In this stage, children overcome egocentrism and begin to have more centric thinking.

    Egocentrism is the tendency to consider reality only from one's own point of view.

    Piaget's study of the conservation of numbers gives us a particular insight into an error typical for children in the second stage, the pre-operational stage of cognitive development, known as the conservation error.

    Conservation of Number Piaget: The Conservation Error

    Children make the conservation error when they fail to recognise that an object can conserve its main qualities despite a change in its appearance.

    Piaget observed that in the pre-operational stage, children tend to assume that if one aspect of the object changes, it must mean that the object is different now.

    If a squishy ball gets flattened and asked if the ball is bigger, the same size or smaller, a child in the pre-operational stage will likely respond that it is smaller.

    Why does the Conservation Error Occur?

    Piaget suggested that the conservation error occurs because of centration.

    Centration refers to a tendency to focus on one aspect of the object while ignoring all the other aspects.

    When one aspect of how an object appears changes, children in the pre-operational stage conclude that the object's main qualities have changed (e.g. it got bigger or smaller).

    For example, focusing on the fact that a flattened plasticine ball appears shorter, without considering that it also got wider, makes children conclude the flattened ball now has less playdough than it did a few seconds ago when it looked differently.

    Piaget's Conservation Task

    Piaget investigated when children make conservation errors using conservation tasks. Conservation tasks help us understand how children understand the qualities of objects.

    During the task, the experimenter changes the appearance of an object by, for example, moving it and asks children whether that affected the object's volume, length or number.

    Examples of Conservation in Piaget's Theory

    We discussed an example of understanding the conservation of solid objects based on a play dough ball. Even though it is flattened, it is still made of the same material.

    According to Piaget, children in the pre-operational stage consistently state that changing the shape of the ball changes its mass.

    To investigate children's understanding of the conservation of liquid, the experimenter first presents a child with the same volume of liquid in two identical glasses. After, the children are asked whether both glasses have the same amount of liquid. The experimenter then pours coloured water from one of the wider glasses into a taller, narrower glass in front of the child.

    Children in the pre-operational stage tend to say the taller glass now contains more liquid than the wider glass, despite seeing previously that the same amount of water was poured.

    Conservation of Number Piaget, Illustration showing how Piaget measured conservation in children, StudySmarterFig. 2 - A demonstration of the conservation of liquid task can show that children in the pre-operational stage have difficulties understanding conservation.

    Children focus on the fact that the level that the liquid reaches changes when the liquid is transferred and disregard the smaller width of the tall glass. Children in the pre-operational stage are likely to conclude that there must be more liquid in the narrow glass than in the wider glass.

    Conservation of number refers to an understanding that the number of objects doesn't change even if they appear to occupy more space because they were spread out.

    To investigate the conservation of numbers, an experimenter puts two rows of coins of equal lengths in front of a child. The child is then asked whether row 1 has more coins, row 2 has more coins or whether they are the same.

    After the child agrees that the two rows are the same, the experimenter spreads the distance between coins in one of the rows and asks the child again which row has more coins.

    Conservation of Number Piaget, Two images with one showing coins equally spaced and the second with coins spread at wider distances then the first, StudySmarterFig. 3 - Children under seven cannot understand equal coins in both rows in the Piaget conservation of number experiment.

    Children below the age of 7 tend to answer that the spread-out row has more coins inaccurately.

    Piaget Conservation of Number Experiment

    The aim of Piaget's experiment was to investigate children's understanding of the conservation of numbers and how it changes with age.

    He conducted cross-sectional studies to compare children's performance at different ages on the conservation task.

    The procedure used was:

    1. Children were shown two rows consisting of an equal number of counters.
    2. The experimenter asked children whether the first row had more counters, the second row had more counters or whether they were the same.
    3. After the child confirmed that the rows were the same, the experimenter changed one of the rows - they spread the objects further apart. Children observed the action.
    4. Children were asked again which row had more counters or whether they were the same.

    Piaget Conservation of Number Experiment: Results

    Piaget found that children below seven stated that the rearranged row had more counters because it was longer. When the appearance of the row changed, children assumed the number of counters also changed.

    By seven, children understood number conservation and didn't make conservation errors.

    Piaget concluded children in the pre-operational stage do not understand that when a row changes in length, it doesn't impact the number of counters.

    This is because they focus on the length of the two rows and ignore the density of the rows. Thus, children in and before the pre-operational stage are not able to understand the concepts of conservation.

    Piaget's Study into the Conservation of Number Evaluation

    Piaget's experiments have made a significant contribution to psychology. He pioneered the study of children's cognitive abilities development, and his findings have been widely replicated. However, his experiments, including the conservation of number experiment, remain heavily criticised.

    Conservation of Number Piaget: Interpreting Adult Intention

    It's been argued that the conservation of numbers Piaget used is confusing for young children because of how they interpret the adult's intentions. When children see the adult performing an intentional action, like changing an aspect of the stimulus, children can think that the action was related to the question and should affect their answer.

    As the child sees the researcher change the length, the child may think that they are expected to answer that the number of coins changes.

    McGarrigle and Donaldson (1974) replicated the Piagetian conservation of number tasks with four to six-year-old children. In one experimental condition, the stimulus was changed due to the experimenter's action. In the second condition, the change was accidental and performed by a "naughty teddy bear".

    Results of the McGarrigle and Donaldson (1974) study revealed:

    • 63% of children showed the ability to conserve when the change was made accidentally by the teddy bear.
    • In the standard Piagetian condition, only 16% of children could conserve.

    It was concluded that children get confused about how they should report what they see after witnessing an adult intentionally move or change stimuli. From the results of the McGarrigle and Donaldson (1974) study, we can see that the conservation of numbers may not reflect children's true abilities.

    Conservation of Number Piaget, Child with speech bubble around head showing confusion, StudySmarterFig. 4. Artificial experiments like the Piagetian conservation of number task can confuse young children.

    Conservation of Number Piaget: Asking Children the Question Twice

    Rose and Blank (1974) recognised that when children are asked the question twice, it can make them think that their first answer was incorrect. In real life, adults often repeat questions that children answer wrong to encourage them to rethink their answers. Therefore asking the question twice in the experiment might affect children's answers.

    Rose and Blank (1974) conducted Piaget's conservation studies but only asked the question once after the changes to the stimuli were made. In their study, six-year-olds often did not make the conservation error.

    These findings suggest that asking two questions can make the task more confusing for children. Perhaps children's understanding of the conservation of numbers may be younger than what Piaget estimated.

    Conservation of Number Piaget: Sample Limitations

    Piaget concluded that conservation error is universal for children under seven. However, he was criticised for concluding that based on his limited sample. He primarily studied his children and didn't report his experiments in a standard way. In the report, he describes his observations but doesn't inform us about the number of participants he tested or their specific characteristics. Therefore, it is difficult to generalise the findings to the general population.


    Conservation of Number Piaget - Key Takeaways

    • Children in the pre-operational stage fail to recognise that an object can conserve its main qualities despite a change in its appearance, which Piaget called the conservation error.
    • The conservation error is made because of centration, which refers to a tendency to focus on one aspect of the object while ignoring all the other aspects.
    • Examples of conservation in Piaget's theory include the conservation of solid, liquid, length and number.

    • Conservation of number task tests if children recognise that the number of counters in a row remains the same even after the length of the row changes.

    • In his study of the conservation of numbers, Piaget found that children below the age of seven fail to conserve numbers.

    • Replications and adaptations of Piaget's original study of the conservation of numbers (1952) found that some children below seven can conserve numbers.

    Frequently Asked Questions about Conservation of Number Piaget

    What is Piaget's theory of conservation?

    Piaget's theory of conservation claims that children below the age of seven fail to recognise that an object can conserve its main qualities despite a change in its appearance. 

    What is conservation in Piaget's concrete operational stage?

    Conservation is the ability to understand that an object can remain the same even if its appearance changes.

    How is conservation defined in Piaget's intuitive phase?

    In the intuitive phase, the late part of the pre-operational stage, conservation is defined as the ability to understand that an object can remain the same even if its appearance changes.

    How to carry out Piaget's conservation test?

    Put an equal amount of coins in two rows of equal length in front of a child and ask them whether one row has more coins or whether they are the same. Next, spread one row out so it looks longer and repeat the question.

    1
    About StudySmarter

    StudySmarter is a globally recognized educational technology company, offering a holistic learning platform designed for students of all ages and educational levels. Our platform provides learning support for a wide range of subjects, including STEM, Social Sciences, and Languages and also helps students to successfully master various tests and exams worldwide, such as GCSE, A Level, SAT, ACT, Abitur, and more. We offer an extensive library of learning materials, including interactive flashcards, comprehensive textbook solutions, and detailed explanations. The cutting-edge technology and tools we provide help students create their own learning materials. StudySmarter’s content is not only expert-verified but also regularly updated to ensure accuracy and relevance.

    Learn more
    StudySmarter Editorial Team

    Team Conservation of Number Piaget Teachers

    • 10 minutes reading time
    • Checked by StudySmarter Editorial Team
    Save Explanation

    Study anywhere. Anytime.Across all devices.

    Sign-up for free

    Sign up to highlight and take notes. It’s 100% free.

    Join over 22 million students in learning with our StudySmarter App

    The first learning app that truly has everything you need to ace your exams in one place

    • Flashcards & Quizzes
    • AI Study Assistant
    • Study Planner
    • Mock-Exams
    • Smart Note-Taking
    Join over 22 million students in learning with our StudySmarter App