What is the difference between Scottish Law and English Law?

Scottish law differs from English law in several ways, most notably in contract law, criminal law, and court structure. Scotland has a mixed legal system with civil law and common law elements, whereas England operates purely on common law.

Is Scottish Law applicable across the whole of the United Kingdom?

No, Scottish Law is not applicable across the whole of the United Kingdom. It is a distinct legal system that applies only in Scotland. England, Wales and Northern Ireland each have their own legal systems.

What are the main principles of Scottish Law?

The main principles of Scottish law include the rule of law, equality before the law, respect for human rights, and the separation of powers. It also adopts a mixture of civil law and common law traditions.

Who enforces Scottish Law and what is their role?

Scottish Law is enforced by Police Scotland and the Procurator Fiscal Service. Police Scotland upholds the law by detecting crime and maintaining public order, while the Procurator Fiscal Service prosecutes offenders and investigates deaths.

How does Scottish Law differ from European Union Law?

Scottish law is a unique legal system with principles based on Roman law, strongly influenced by common law. European Union law is a system of supranational law, emphasising directives and regulations across member states. Scottish law primarily focuses on specifics of domestic and regional matters, while EU law centres on broader European policy, economic issues, and human rights.

What influences shaped the historical development of Scottish Law?

Celtic legal traditions, Roman Civil law through the Church, Feudal law from the 12th century, and the Act of Union in 1707 all influenced Scottish Law.

What are the main branches of Scottish Law?

The main branches of Scottish Law are Civil Law and Criminal Law. Civil law deals with non-criminal disputes between individuals or organisations, while criminal law relates to offences against society.

What is the process of prosecution under the Scottish Criminal Law?

The process includes criminal investigation, criminal charge and arrest, court proceedings, and sentencing if the defendant is found guilty.

What are some basic principles of the Scottish legal system?

Some basic principles are Legal Writings (Probative), Corroboration and Warranty. The first one is about formal self-proving written agreements, the second one requires every crucial fact to be independently testified by two sources, and the last one assures the buyer about conditions or facts of provided goods or services.

Scottish Law: Overview & Key Principles

Scottish Law

Delve into the intriguing world of Scottish Law with this comprehensive guide. Ideal for students, it offers a step-by-step exploration, from the historical roots of Scottish Law to its basic principles. Detailing crucial laws within the Scottish civil and criminal systems, it also provides an in-depth understanding of litigation processes and the roles of various courts. Furthermore, context is given to key household, property, education, and health laws, along with laws on crimes against persons and property in Scotland. This article offers a foundation for your understanding and study of the unique Scottish Legal System.

Get started

Scottish Law: An Understanding for Students

What is Scottish Law? - An Overview

You might have heard about different legal systems around the world. But have you ever wondered about Scottish Law? In simple terms, Scottish Law can be defined as the legal system that operates in Scotland. It is a part of the UK's legal institutions, but it maintains its unique characteristics and principles.

Scottish Law: It's the legal system which operates in Scotland, maintaining its uniqueness while being a part of the wider UK legal institutions.

Just like many legal systems, it includes a combination of common law traditions and statutory laws. However, there is more to Scottish Law than meets the eye.

For instance, unlike the law system in England, Scottish Law uses a mixed legal system with both civil law and common law traditions, which gives it a more versatile outlook.

Roots of Scottish Law: Historical Development

One cannot understand Scottish Law without delving into some history. Its roots go back to several centuries when unofficial legal customs were followed. They gradually evolved into formally recognized systems.

Celtic legal traditions played a remarkable role in shaping ancient Scottish Law.
Roman Civil Law influenced Scottish Law through the Church – an element it still retains.
From the 12th century onwards, Feudal Law was introduced.
The Act of Union in 1707 let Scotland retain its unique legal traditions.

Basic Principles of the Scottish Legal System

Over centuries of development, some basic principles that underlie the Scottish legal system have solidified.

Legal Principles: These are fundamental assumptions or accepted truths that form the basis of a legal system.

Let's look at some of these principles of the Scottish Legal System:

Legal Writings (Probative)	These are formal written agreements that are self-proving and don't require further proof.
Corroboration	Each crucial fact must be testified by two independent sources.
Warranty	It assures the buyer about certain conditions or facts about goods or services provided.

These are just a few among several hundreds of principles that shape the uniqueness of Scottish Law.

Interestingly, the Scottish legal system's principle of 'Corroboration' has been a topic of ongoing debate, with some arguing that it enhances the quality of evidence while others propose it hampers access to justice.

Breaking Down Scottish Laws You Should Know

Looking to understand Scottish Law in detail? Let's take a deep-dive into some important aspects, covering both civil and criminal aspects. To simplify, we've categorized them under Scottish Civil Law and Scottish Criminal Law.

Important Laws in the Scottish Civil Law

Just as in any other legal system, civil law in Scotland deals with disputes between individuals or organizations. Here, we'll explore some critical areas like household, property, education, and health service laws.

Scottish Household and Property Laws

Household and property laws in Scotland are vital for maintaining peace and settling disputes that may arise related to properties. An understanding of these laws can significantly help smooth property transactions and dealing with related disputes.

Conveyancing: This is the legal process involved in buying and selling property. It includes transferring ownership from one person to another.

Besides, Scottish law identifies two types of property: heritable and moveable. Heritable refers to land and buildings, while moveable refers to everything else.

Heritable Property	Land and buildings (like your home or office).
Moveable Property	Everything else (like your car, furniture, or jewellery).

Much of Scots property law's essence lies in a unique concept, the 'allodial system.' Under this system, there is a direct relationship between the property owner and the Crown. For household properties, this law also extends to tenancy rights and housing contracts.

Curiously, under this system, there are no lands in Scotland that are not owned by someone. Even those lands appearing ownerless belong to the Crown.

Laws regarding Scottish Education and Health Services

Your awareness about Scottish Law can't be complete without laws on education and health. These sectors govern the rights and welfare of the public.

State Education: This refers to the education system that's publicly funded and controlled by the state or government.

National Health Service (NHS): This refers to the publicly funded healthcare system in Scotland.

Scotland has an entirely different Education Act that sets standards for the quality of teaching and managing schools. Similarly, Health and Mental Health Acts regulate various aspects of healthcare services, patient rights, and medical practices.

Noteworthy Laws in the Scottish Criminal Law

While civil law maintains civil society's orderliness, criminal law in Scotland ensures justice when someone commits a crime. It deals with offences related to persons and property.

Laws on Crimes Against Persons in Scotland

Crimes against persons in Scotland span a broad spectrum. They include offences causing physical injury or mental distress, such as assault, murder, or stalking.

Assault: An intentional act by one person that creates an apprehension in another of an imminent harmful or offensive contact.

Stalking: A pattern of unwanted, fixated and obsessive behaviour which is intrusive. It can include harassment and cyberstalking.

Within Scottish Law, individuals accused of such crimes have rights, including the right not to self-incriminate and the right to legal representation.

Laws on Crimes Against Property in Scotland

Crimes against the property in Scotland typically revolve around theft, burglary, and arson. Acts like shoplifting fall under this category too.

Burglary: It involves trespassing into a building with the intention to commit a crime, such as stealing or causing damage.

Law enforcement in Scotland follows precise protocols while dealing with property crimes, with distinct processes for searching properties, collecting evidence, and presenting them in court.

Deeper Into Scottish Law: Civil and Criminal Systems

As you continue your exploration of Scottish Law, you'll find it composed of two main branches - civil law and criminal law. Each of these branches, while interrelated, serves its unique role in preserving justice and maintaining societal order. Let's delve deeper into these systems and understand their workings better.

An Examination of Scottish Civil Law - Definition and Key Aspects

Scottish Civil Law covers a wide range of legal issues, dealing with non-criminal disputes between individuals, organisations, or both. While the goal of civil law is primarily about resolving disputes and providing compensation to the aggrieved party.

Scottish Civil Law: This refers to the aspect of law concerning non-criminal disputes between individuals, organisations or both, where the purpose of litigation is to resolve the dispute and provide compensation, if applicable.

Litigation Process in Scottish Civil Law

The litigation process begins when a person or organisation, known as the plaintiff, files a claim or complaint against another party, referred to as the defendant, for a civil wrong or breach of contract.

Litigation: This is a process where a case (or a 'suit') is brought to a court to resolve the dispute.

For example, if a tenant believes their landlord has violated their rental agreement by failing to repair faulty plumbing, the tenant can start a litigation process against the landlord within the Scottish Civil Law system.

The stages involved in the litigation process are:

Filing Of The Claim
Response From The Defendant
Pre-Trial Process And Discovery
Trial
Appeal (If Necessary)

At any stage of the process, the parties can agree to settle the dispute, either through negotiation or alternative dispute resolution mechanisms like mediation or arbitration.

Role of the Sheriff Court and Court of Session in Scottish Civil Law

The Scottish civil court system is composed of the Sheriff Courts and the Court of Session. These courts play a pivotal role in administering Scottish Civil Law.

Sheriff Courts: These are local courts where most civil cases are dealt with. Each of Scotland's six sheriffdoms, each headed by a Sheriff Principal, has multiple Sheriff Courts.
Court of Session: This is the highest civil court in Scotland. It hears complex and high-value cases. It comprises the Outer House for first-instance cases and the Inner House as an appeal court.

Exploration of Scottish Criminal Law - Understanding the Basics

Scottish Criminal Law is all about dealing with offences against society as a whole. From petty crimes like shoplifting to severe crimes like murder, this branch of Scottish law serves to maintain order and safety in society.

Scottish Criminal Law: This branch of law relates to offences against society, where the purpose is to punish the offender. The severity of the punishment depends on the nature of the crime.

The Process of Prosecution under Scottish Criminal Law

The process of prosecution begins when an individual is suspected of committing a crime. The process includes the following stages:

Criminal Investigation
Criminal Charge And Arrest
Court Proceedings
Sentencing (If Found Guilty)

The Procurator Fiscal, Scotland’s public prosecutor, has the responsibility to decide whether to prosecute an individual and what charges should be brought forward.

Role of the High Court of Justiciary in Scottish Criminal Law

The High Court of Justiciary is Scotland's highest criminal court. It hears the most serious crimes, including murder and rape.

Interestingly, the High Court of Justiciary serves a dual role. It acts as a court of first instance for serious crimes and an appeal court for criminal matters from both the Sheriff Courts and the Justice of the Peace Courts.

Understanding the role of these various courts in the Scottish law system leads to a richer picture of how justice is maintained in Scotland, emphasising the diligence and commitment of the Scottish people towards upholding societal order and justice.

Scottish Law - Key takeaways

Scottish Law: It's the legal system that operates in Scotland, maintaining its uniqueness while being a part of the wider UK legal institutions and employing a mixed legal system with both civil law and common law traditions.
Historical development of Scottish Law: Ancient Scottish Law was shaped by Celtic legal traditions, influenced by Roman Civil Law through the Church and Feudal law from the 12th century. Scotland's unique legal traditions were retained after the Act of Union in 1707.
Principles of Scottish Legal System include Legal Writings (Probative), which are self-proving written agreements; Corroboration, which means that each crucial fact must be testified by two independent sources; and Warranty, which assures the buyer about certain conditions or facts regarding goods or services.
Scottish Civil Law: This involves legal disputes between individuals or organisations. Important laws include those governing household and property, education, and health services.
Scottish Criminal Law: This branch of law concerns offences against persons and property. The process of prosecution involves criminal investigation, the criminal charge and arrest, court proceedings and sentencing (if found guilty), with the Procurator Fiscal serving as public prosecutor.

Scottish Law

Create learning materials about Scottish Law with our free learning app!