Postmodernist Perspective on The Family

The world is steadily and rapidly changing all the time. If asked, we can probably list many examples of this. However, we are unlikely to mention differences in the family as part of these major changes in society. 

Get started

Review generated flashcards

Sign up for free
You have reached the daily AI limit

Start learning or create your own AI flashcards

Contents
Contents

Jump to a key chapter

    We will be looking at postmodernist perspectives on the family.

    • First, we'll consider the definition of postmodernism in sociology.
    • Next, we will look at postmodernist views on the nuclear family and family diversity.
    • We will then look at postmodernist views on divorce and consider some examples of a postmodern family.
    • Lastly, we will evaluate the postmodern perspective on family.

    Let's get started!

    Postmodernism in sociology: definition

    Before we consider postmodernist viewpoints, it may be helpful to have a general reminder of the concept.

    Postmodernism, also known as postmodernity, is a sociological theory that, according to the Cambridge Dictionary of Sociology (p.459):

    arose as a consequence of advanced modernization."

    Postmodern theorists believe that the era we are living in can be classed as postmodern due to its fundamental differences from the age of modernity. This monumental change leads sociologists to argue that society must also be studied differently now.

    You can find an article on 'Postmodernism' here at StudySmarter for more detail about this time period.

    Now that we have outlined the broad theory of postmodernism, let us consider how postmodernists view the family.

    Followers of postmodernism note that there are several key features that characterise postmodern families. We will go through these key features in turn.

    Postmodernist views on the nuclear family

    Postmodernists argue that we should look at family as a fluid and changing concept. Therefore, they disagree with theories such as functionalism, which argues that there is one 'ideal' or 'normal' family type (the nuclear family). It also disagrees with theories such as Marxism, which makes generalisations about families.

    Broad ideas and generalisations about how society works are called metanarratives. Theories such as functionalism and Marxism are metanarratives.

    According to postmodernists, the decreasing relevance of metanarratives is a key feature of postmodernism.

    Postmodernist views on family diversity

    Postmodernist theorists claim that family is unique for everyone and that family dynamics or interactions cannot (and should not) be generalised.

    This is evident in the increase in alternative family types, such as:

    • single-parent families
    • reconstituted families
    • same-sex parent families

    Postmodernist views on divorce

    In addition, postmodernists note that divorce rates are increasing, which means the family and its structures are likely to continue changing for many people. However, postmodernists do not necessarily see divorce as a bad thing, as remaining in a marriage can sometimes be problematic.

    Sociologist John Bernades argues that in cases of domestic violence, stress, health issues, or general dissatisfaction, divorce may actually help to alleviate problems that appear with remaining married. In this way, divorce may be a solution.

    Unlike functionalists, Bernades argues that divorce is not necessarily a 'social problem'. He states that if functionalists were to acknowledge the problems in married life, they would be less likely to view divorce as a sign of anomie or a threat to solidarity.

    Postmodernist Perspective on The Family, Dad with daughter hugging and laughing in field, StudySmarterFig. 1 - Postmodernists state that the rise of alternative family types means we cannot make generalisations about families.

    Changes in attitudes to romantic and sexual relationships

    Postmodernists argue that due to changes in attitudes towards romantic and sexual connections, the importance of family life has changed.

    Due to the declining stigma attached to premarital sex and relationships in the West, individuals have more opportunities to 'find the one' and explore different partnerships before settling down to marry. Individuals are therefore more experienced and have higher standards for marriage, compared to more traditional times.

    Additionally, the acts of marriage and starting a family do not serve as many functional purposes as before. For example, women were expected to marry for financial support and men were expected to marry, so they could have children. Nowadays, individuals are more likely to marry for love, which means they may marry later in life as they do not have to think about functionality.

    It is important to also consider the rise in acceptance of non-heterosexual relationships. In many countries, homosexuality is decriminalised, and gay marriage is legal, which means individuals have more freedom to be themselves and find partners. This can create many different family types.

    You can find out more about marriage rates in the UK in recent years by visiting our 'Changing Patterns' section here on StudySmarter.

    Child-free lifestyles

    Many people, especially women, are now leading child-free lifestyles, which means they choose not to have children. They are likely to characterise family in other ways - they may refer to their romantic partners, immediate family, other relatives or friends.

    There are several reasons why individuals decide against having children, including:

    • the rising costs of raising children
    • concerns about raising children in unstable environments, such as during economic crises or climate change
    • they want to focus on their career
    • it may simply not appeal to them!

    Changes in medical technology

    Relatively recent changes in medical technology have allowed for greater freedom to control fertility and reproduction. Medical advancements include:

    • IVF
    • egg and sperm freezing
    • surrogacy
    • test-tube babies
    • hormonal treatment for infertility
    • embryo transplants

    Not only do these advancements allow for greater reproductive choice for people overall, but they also create opportunities for single, gay or older individuals to have families without assuming traditional nuclear family structures.

    Postmodernist Perspective on The Family, Newborn baby feet in blanket, StudySmarterFig. 2 - Medical advancements give individuals more choice and freedom to have families. You no longer need a traditional nuclear family structure

    Postmodern family: examples

    We will now go through some examples of postmodern families. These are theorised by postmodernists who look at the different types of families in postmodernist times and how they should be studied.

    Judith Stacey: "Divorce-extended family"

    In particular, Judith Stacey (1998) highlights the increased freedom enjoyed by women to create their own family structures in postmodern times. She identified the "divorce-extended family", a family type where family members are connected through divorce, not marriage.

    People may maintain relations and connections with their ex-spouse's family members, such as their parents.

    Due to various changes in society over the years, women are no longer restricted to one type of family arrangement; they can create family structures to suit their individual needs. As a result, their life choices may be very diverse and fluid in comparison to traditional eras where women had limited choices in shaping their lives.

    It is no longer unacceptable or unconventional for women to decide to focus on their careers until their thirties (for instance) and decide to have children at that age.

    On a similar note, it is not unusual for a woman to start a business or go back to employment or education at a later age in life after having had kids.

    Stacey argues that family life is characterised by diversity, not alikeness.

    Carol Smart: The Sociology of Personal Life

    Sociologist Carol Smart (2007) argues that we should study relationships using the lens of 'personal life' rather than 'family', as the former is a more neutral term.

    The term is broad enough to consider all types of personal relationships that may not fall under the narrow scope of 'family' but are still very meaningful to people. Examples of these include:

    • Relationships with former partners or spouses and their families
    • Long-distance relationships
    • Close connections with neighbours or colleagues
    • Pets

    She argues that relationships can go beyond biological relations or connections through marriage.

    Tamara Harevan: Life Course Analysis

    Social historian Tamara Harevan (2000) states it is important to consider individuals' life courses instead of their families. This involves studying people's choices throughout their lives as they experience key events such as marriage, parenthood, divorce, or the death of a loved one.

    The argument is that individuals will experience and move through several family types or relationships throughout their lifetime. Harevan argues it is important to study the meanings people give to these life events.

    In doing so, we may clearly see people's choices, why they were made, and the influence of external factors (such as patriarchy, social class, ethnicity, religion or social pressure) on them. We can understand what is important to people and why.

    Some people may choose to become doctors because they feel pressured to do so by cultural and familial expectations. From this, we may be able to understand that observing their cultural background and listening to family members is important to them.

    If we study people's life courses instead of simply their families, we can understand family diversity in greater detail.

    Postmodernist Perspective on The Family, Icon of books and paw print and rings and gravestone representing different milestones in life, StudySmarterSome postmodern sociologists believe we should focus on life events and key personal relationships. StudySmarter Originals, Shikha Shah

    Criticisms of postmodern perspectives on family

    We will now consider some criticisms of postmodern views on the family.

    • Although postmodernist theorists claim to be against the use of metanarratives, postmodernism itself has been claimed to be a metanarrative, as they make generalisations about the fluidity and modern nature of society.
    • Structural factors such as race, gender and social class still impact a significant amount of people's lives and choices. There is not as much choice with personal relationships as claimed by postmodernists.
    • Late modernist sociologists such as Anthony Giddens and Ulrich Beck claim that we are not yet in a postmodernist society; therefore, we still retain a lot of elements of modernist family patterns and experiences. We are not as 'free' to make choices as suggested by postmodernism as we are still in late modern society.
    • Having more choice can be good, but some sociologists such as Giddens argue that too much choice and diversity can lead to instability. This is because any of the partners can end the relationship at will.
    • Robert Chester asserts that the nuclear family type is still dominant. Although there is increased family diversity, postmodernist claims are exaggerated.
    • Feminists believe that although women have more freedom to make their own choices, they are still harshly judged by wider society for not conforming to traditional familial expectations e.g. having children.
    • Functionalists argue that the nuclear family is the ideal family type because it maintains social solidarity and keeps society functioning smoothly.

    Postmodernist Perspective on The Family - Key takeaways

    • Postmodernists believe we should look at family as a fluid and changing concept; therefore, they disagree with using metanarratives such as functionalism and Marxism.
    • Postmodernists note the increase in alternative family types, such as single-parent, reconstituted, and same-sex families.
    • Changes in attitudes to romantic and sexual relationships have also impacted the importance of family life.
    • Many individuals choose to have child-free lifestyles, which means they are likely to characterise family differently.
    • Judith Stacey, Carol Smart and Tamara Harevan all speak about alternative ways of studying individuals' families.
    Learn faster with the 1 flashcards about Postmodernist Perspective on The Family

    Sign up for free to gain access to all our flashcards.

    Postmodernist Perspective on The Family
    Frequently Asked Questions about Postmodernist Perspective on The Family

    What is the postmodern perspective in sociology?

    The postmodern perspective in sociology, generally, is that society is living in a postmodern era, which means we have to study society differently. Due to important changes such as globalisation, fragmentation and advancements in technology, society is very different and this has affected the way it works.

    What do postmodernists believe about marriage?

    Postmodernists believe that due to the declining stigma towards premarital sex and relations, individuals have more opportunities to 'find the one' and explore different relationships before settling down to marry. People, therefore, have more experience and higher standards for marriage. Also, individuals are less likely to marry for functional reasons and more likely to marry for love.

    What is Giddens's view of the family?

    Anthony Giddens is a late modernist who argues that although we have experienced a lot of changes, we still retain a lot of elements of modernist family patterns and experiences. Therefore, we are not yet in a postmodern society and we are not as 'free' to make choices about family as postmodernists believe. Giddens also stated that too much choice and diversity can lead to instability.

    What is the postmodernist view on family diversity?

    Postmodernists argue that we should look at family as a fluid and changing concept. Therefore, the perspective disagrees with theories such as functionalism, which argues that there is one 'ideal' or 'normal' family type (the nuclear family). It also disagrees with theories such as Marxism, which makes generalisations about families. Postmodernists claim that family is unique for everyone and that family dynamics or interactions cannot (and should not) be generalised. 

    This is evident by the increase in alternative family types, such as single-parent, reconstituted and same-sex families.

    What is a postmodern family? 

    A postmodern family is a family that is characterised by living in postmodern society. Its features, therefore, may include family diversity, individual choices and personal relationships that go beyond biological or marriage ties.

    Save Article

    Discover learning materials with the free StudySmarter app

    Sign up for free
    1
    About StudySmarter

    StudySmarter is a globally recognized educational technology company, offering a holistic learning platform designed for students of all ages and educational levels. Our platform provides learning support for a wide range of subjects, including STEM, Social Sciences, and Languages and also helps students to successfully master various tests and exams worldwide, such as GCSE, A Level, SAT, ACT, Abitur, and more. We offer an extensive library of learning materials, including interactive flashcards, comprehensive textbook solutions, and detailed explanations. The cutting-edge technology and tools we provide help students create their own learning materials. StudySmarter’s content is not only expert-verified but also regularly updated to ensure accuracy and relevance.

    Learn more
    StudySmarter Editorial Team

    Team Sociology Teachers

    • 10 minutes reading time
    • Checked by StudySmarter Editorial Team
    Save Explanation Save Explanation

    Study anywhere. Anytime.Across all devices.

    Sign-up for free

    Sign up to highlight and take notes. It’s 100% free.

    Join over 22 million students in learning with our StudySmarter App

    The first learning app that truly has everything you need to ace your exams in one place

    • Flashcards & Quizzes
    • AI Study Assistant
    • Study Planner
    • Mock-Exams
    • Smart Note-Taking
    Join over 22 million students in learning with our StudySmarter App
    Sign up with Email