Lerne mit deinen Freunden und bleibe auf dem richtigen Kurs mit deinen persönlichen Lernstatistiken
Jetzt kostenlos anmeldenNie wieder prokastinieren mit unseren Lernerinnerungen.
Jetzt kostenlos anmeldenThere are many competing perspectives in the study of development in sociology. Modernisation theory is a particularly controversial one.
Modernisation theory sheds light upon the cultural barriers to development, arguing that the conservative traditions and values of developing countries hold them back from developing.
The two key aspects of modernisation theory are in relation to:
Explaining why economically 'backwards' countries are poor
Providing a way out of underdevelopment.
However, while it focuses on cultural barriers, some modernisation theorists, such as Jeffery Sachs (2005), consider economic barriers to development.
The central argument of modernisation theory is that developing countries need to follow the same path as the West in order to develop. They must adapt to Western cultures and values and industrialise their economies. However, these countries would require support from the West - through their governments and companies - to do so.
By the end of WWII, many countries in Asia, Africa, and South America failed to develop and remained economically weak, despite developing capitalist structures.
Leaders of developed nations and regions like the US and Europe were concerned about communism spreading in these developing countries, as that could potentially harm Western business interests. In this context, modernisation theory was created.
It provided a non-communist means to break out of poverty in developing countries, specifically spreading an industrialised, capitalist system of development based on Western ideologies.
Modernisation theory favours an industrial model of development, where large-scale production is encouraged to take place in factories instead of small workshops or in-house. For example, car plants or conveyor belts should be utilised.
In this scenario, private money is invested in producing goods for sale to generate profit, not for personal consumption.
Modernisation theorists suggest that the obstacles to development lie deep within developing countries' cultural values and social systems. These value systems prevent them from growing internally.
According to Talcott Parsons, underdeveloped countries are too attached to traditional practices, customs, and rituals. Parsons claimed that these traditional values were the ‘enemy of progress’. He was mainly critical of the kinship ties and tribal practices in traditional societies, which, according to him, hindered a country’s development.
Parsons addressed the following traditional values of developing countries in Asia, Africa, and America that, in his view, act as barriers to development:
Individuals are assigned titles or roles out of their personal or familial ties with those already in powerful positions.
A suitable example of this would be a politician or a company CEO giving a relative or a member of their ethnic group a job opportunity simply because of their shared background, instead of giving it based on merit.
People are expected to put the interests of the group ahead of themselves. This can lead to scenarios where children are expected to quit school at a young age to take care of parents or grandparents rather than continue pursuing education.
Patriarchal structures are ingrained in many developing countries, which means that women remain restricted to traditional household roles and rarely gain any powerful political or economic positions.
An individual’s social standing is often determined at birth - based on caste, gender, or ethnic group. For instance, caste consciousness in India, slave systems, etc.
Fatalism, a feeling that nothing can be done to change the situation, is a possible outcome of this.
In comparison, Parsons argued in favour of Western values and cultures, which he believed promoted growth and competition. These include:
As opposed to collectivism, people put their self-interests ahead of their family, clan, or ethnic group. This enables individuals to focus on self-improvement and grow in life using their skills and talents.
In contrast to particularism, universalism judges everyone according to the same standards, with no bias. People are not judged based on their relations to anyone but on their talent.
Individuals achieve success based on their own efforts and merit. Theoretically, in a meritocratic society, those who work hardest and are the most talented will be rewarded with success, power, and status. It is technically possible for anyone to occupy the most powerful positions in society, such as the head of a large corporation or a country leader.
Though there are numerous debates on the most productive way to aid developing countries, there is agreement on one point - if these nations are helped with money and Western expertise, traditional or ‘backwards’ cultural barriers can be knocked down and lead to economic growth.
One of the most prominent modernisation theorists was Walt Whitman Rostow (1960). He proposed five stages through which countries must pass to become developed.
Initially, the local economy in 'traditional societies' remains dominated by subsistence agricultural production. Such societies don’t have sufficient wealth to invest in or access modern industry and advanced technology.
Rostow suggests that cultural barriers persist during this phase and lays out the following processes to combat them.
In this stage, Western practices are brought in to set up investment conditions, bring more companies into developing countries, etc. These include:
Science and technology – to improve agricultural practices
Infrastructure – to improve the condition of roads and city communications
Industry – setting up factories for large-scale production
During this next phase, advanced modern techniques become norms of society, driving economic development. With the reinvestment of profits, an urbanised, entrepreneurial class emerges, leading the country towards progress. Society has become willing to take more risks and invest beyond subsistence production.
When the country can consume new products by importing and exporting goods, it generates more wealth that eventually gets distributed to the entire population.
With increased economic growth and investment in other areas — media, education, population control, etc. — society becomes aware of potential opportunities and strives toward making the most out of them.
This stage occurs for an extended period of time, as industrialisation is fully implemented, living standards rise with investment in education and health, the use of technology increases, and the national economy grows and diversifies.
This is the final and - Rostow believed - the ultimate stage: development. A country's economy flourishes in a capitalist market, marked by mass production and consumerism. Western countries such as the U.S.A. are currently occupying this stage.
This brief section takes a look at some examples of the implementation of modernisation theory in the real world.
Indonesia partially followed modernisation theory by encouraging Western organisations to invest and accepting financial aid in the form of loans from the World Bank in the 1960s.
The Green Revolution: when India and Mexico received help through Western biotechnology.
The eradication of smallpox with the help of vaccine donations from Russia and the USA.
There is no example showcasing a country's experience of undergoing all the stages of development specified above. Modernisation theory is structured in a way that justifies the dominance of Western capitalist countries during the colonial period.
The theory assumes that the West is superior to the non-West. It implies that Western culture and practices have greater value than traditional values and practices in other regions.
Developed countries are not perfect - they have a range of inequalities that give rise to poverty, inequality, mental and physical health issues, increased crime rates, drug abuse, etc.
Dependency theorists argue that Western development theories are actually concerned with changing societies to make dominance and exploitation easier. They believe capitalist development aims to generate more wealth and extract cheap raw materials and labour from developing countries to benefit developed nations.
Neoliberals criticise modernisation theory and stress how corrupt elites or even government officials can obstruct financial aid from actually helping the economic growth of developing countries. This also creates more inequality and helps the elite to exercise power and control dependent countries. Neoliberalism also believes that obstacles to development are internal to the country and that the focus should be on economic policies and institutions rather than cultural values and practices.
Post-development thinkers believe that the primary weakness of modernisation theory is assuming that outside forces are needed to help a country develop. For them, this negatively affects local practices, initiatives, and beliefs; and is a demeaning approach toward local populations.
Eduardo Galeano (1992) explains that, in the process of colonisation, the mind also becomes colonised with the belief that it is dependent on outside forces. Colonising powers condition developing nations and their citizens to be incapable and then offer ‘aid’. He argues for alternative means of development, citing, for example, Communist Cuba.
Some argue that industrialisation causes more harm than good. Projects like the development of dams have led to the displacement of local populations, who are removed forcibly from their homes with insufficient or no compensation.
Despite its drawbacks, modernisation theory remains an influential theory in terms of its impact on international affairs. The essence of the theory gave rise to organisations such as the United Nations, World Bank, etc. that continue to aid and support less developed countries. It must be noted, though, that there is a debate on whether this is the best practice to ensure development.
Jeffrey Sachs, a ‘neo-modernisation theorist’, suggests that development is a ladder and that there are people who cannot climb it. This is because they lack the type of capital needed for it e.g. good health, education, knowledge, savings, etc. which the West takes for granted. Sachs argues that these people are deprived and need specific aid from the West to develop.
According to Sachs (2005) there are a billion people who are practically trapped in cycles of deprivation - 'development traps' - and need aid injections from the developed countries in the West to develop. In 2000, Sachs calculated the amount of money required to fight and eradicate poverty, finding that it would need 0.7% of the GNP of about 30 of the most developed nations for the upcoming decades.1
Modernisation theory throws light upon cultural barriers to development, arguing that the conservative traditions and values of developing countries hold them back from developing.
The two key aspects of modernisation theory are in relation to:
Walt Rostow proposes the different stages of development where support from the West will help developing nations progress:
The preconditions for take-off
Take off stage
The drive to maturity
The age of high mass consumption
Modernisation theorists suggest that the obstacles to development lie deep within developing countries' cultural values and social systems. These value systems prevent them from growing internally.
One of the most prominent modernisation theorists was Walt Whitman Rostow (1960). He proposed five stages through which countries must pass to become developed.
How did modernisation theory emerge?
Leaders of developed countries such as the US were concerned about communism getting spread in these developing countries, as that could potentially harm western business interests. In this regard, the modernisation theory emerged.
What is the relevance of modernisation theory to developing countries?
Modernisation theory throws light upon cultural barriers to development - arguing that the conservative traditions and values of developing countries hold them back from developing.
What is a Capitalist-Industrial model?
An industrial model of development is where large-scale production is encouraged to take place in a factory instead of a small workshop or in-house. For example, car plants or conveyor belts, etc. In this scenario, private money is invested to make goods that are up for sale in the marketplace in order to generate profit, and not for private consumption.
What is 'particularism'?
Individuals are assigned titles or roles out of their personal or familial ties with those already in powerful positions. A suitable example of this would be a politician or the boss of a company giving their relative or someone belonging to their ethnic group or locality the position simply because of the relationship they share, instead of giving it to someone who has the skill or talent suitable for the position.
What is 'collectivism'?
People are expected to put the interests of the group ahead of themselves - a scenario where children at a young age are expected to quit school to take care of parents or grandparents rather than continue pursuing education.
What is Talcott Parson’s perspective on modernisation theory?
According to Talcott Parson, underdeveloped countries were too attached to traditional practices, customs, and rituals. Parsons claimed that these traditional values were the ‘enemy of progress’. He was mainly critical of the kinship ties and tribal practices in traditional societies, which according to him hindered a country’s development.
Already have an account? Log in
Open in AppThe first learning app that truly has everything you need to ace your exams in one place
Sign up to highlight and take notes. It’s 100% free.
Save explanations to your personalised space and access them anytime, anywhere!
Sign up with Email Sign up with AppleBy signing up, you agree to the Terms and Conditions and the Privacy Policy of StudySmarter.
Already have an account? Log in
Already have an account? Log in
The first learning app that truly has everything you need to ace your exams in one place
Already have an account? Log in