Of Mice and Men Chapter 5

In Of Mice and Men (1937) chapter 5, things spiral out of control. In the previous chapters, there had always been the possibility that things would be okay. After what happens between Lennie and Curley's wife in the barn, there's no turning back. The dream is over.

Of Mice and Men Chapter 5 Summary

The chapter opens with Lennie alone in the barn. He's petting his dead puppy. He talks to it, saying he didn't know he'd kill it. Frustrated that this might cost him the chance to tend the rabbits at the dream farm, he tosses it. He picks it up again and pets it.

Curley's wife comes by. The other workers are knee-deep in a horseshoes game, and she wants some company. Hiding the dead puppy and in frustrated spirits, Lennie tells her that he's not supposed to talk to her. Without George to steer him, though, he doesn't stand a chance at refusing her.

She continues talking to him, first about how he hurt Curley. She's happy about what he did because she doesn't like Curley or this place. This leads her to talk about how she ended up here. She had wanted to be a movie star and even met someone from Hollywood who said she was perfect and would write to her. However, no letter came. Curley's wife thinks her mother hid the letter from her. Either way, she ended up marrying Curley.

Fig. 1 - Curley's wife is dissatisfied with how her life has panned out.

Lennie isn't attentive to any of this, though. He can't stop thinking about what to do with the dead puppy in order to get George's approval to tend the rabbits. Curley's wife calls him "nuts" and like a "big baby." She asks him why he's so obsessed with rabbits anyway. He says it's because he petted a long-haired one at a fair once.

Fig. 1 - Tragically, Lennie destroys the small, soft animals he loves because of his physical strength.

Seeing this as a way to flirt with him, Curley's wife puts his hand on her hair, which is very soft. She says not to mess it up, though. As the reader knows, Lennie has very little control over his hands. He starts messing up her hair, tangling it. She shouts, and he holds on. She screams, and he covers her mouth. He tells her to please not scream. She struggles, and he holds her down, eventually breaking her neck.

Lennie partially covers her up in hay, saying he's done another bad thing. Leaving her near his dead puppy, he runs away.

Candy comes by. He tells the body of Curley's wife that she shouldn't be sleeping in the barn, only to realize she's dead. He runs to get the others. Slim confirms her neck is broken. Curley knows Lennie did it. Getting Crooks's shotgun, he leads away the men in search of Lennie. He intends to lynch him or otherwise. Before Candy leaves, he curses at Curley's dead wife, saying this is all her fault.

As for George, he tries to tell the others that Lennie didn't mean it, but that excuse isn't going to help Lennie this time, and George knows it. George tells them to go the wrong way, hoping he can find Lennie first. At the same time, Carlson thinks Lennie took his luger, but it seems clear that someone else pocketed it.

Of Mice and Men Chapter 5 Analysis

The dream is shattered in chapter 5 of Of Mice and Men. The chapter begins peaceful enough, and the reader goes on to learn about the dreams of Curley's wife. However, any hope for her or Lennie evaporates when Lennie kills her. The reader knows that there's no turning back.

Near the end of the chapter, Candy casts the blame for all this happening on Curley's wife.

Sniveling selfishly at this tragic, senseless loss of life, the reader should dismiss Candy's assessment. All Candy cares about is his own future — no one else's.

Curley's wife is hardly a femme fatale or a seductress.

Curley's wife is not this. Steinbeck paints her sympathetically, and she only got married to Curley to get away from her controlling mother. Like many of the characters, Curley's wife wants freedom, something she didn't get when she married Curley, unsurprisingly.

The cause for much of the pain in the novella is Lennie.

Lennie creates fights and causes death. In the barn, the fault lies with Lennie, who killed someone. This is very much in keeping with the novel's themes, though, because Lennie lacks control over his actions more than anyone else.

Lennie is like a mouse whose life is left up to chance. There is very little he can do, which means that in some sense the fault in this story lies in the unfairness and cruelty of life itself. This is the crux of the question posed in the story's final chapter.

Dreams in Of Mice and Men

This chapter gives us a complete perspective of the characters who have dreams. Here is a chart of the characters and their dreams.

So Lennie and George are not the only one to experience dreams and shattered dreams. This ties back into the idea that this is a universal story: a story relevant to the past, present, and future.

Of Mice and Men Chapter 5 Quotes

The following quotes are all from Of Mice and Men chapter 5. This first quote comes from the conversation between Lennie and Curley's wife.

There's no indication one way or another, but it's interesting to imagine what happened to that letter. Did her mother steal it, or did the guy simply get her hopes up? Either way, Curley's wife had no control over it.

In this chapter, we see a different side of Lennie. Lennie is by far the most menacing he has ever been, and he gets mad twice in this chapter. In the first instance, he throws his dead puppy, blaming it, thinking George won't let him tend rabbits because he killed it. The second instance is when he kills Curley's wife.

Note the repetition. Twice, the narrator describes Lennie as "angry." This is important, and it shows that Lennie is actually quite scary. He's so scary because he can kill people.

Characters seem to find peace in death. Slim killed some puppies as a mercy killing, and then Carlson killed Candy's dog as a mercy killing. The slaying of Curley's wife is not a mercy killing, but it's interesting that it resulted in some kind of peace.